Sunday, April 5, 2020

Exit 8 – The Pilgrims at Plimouth Planation, Massachusetts


Pilgrims established a new beachhead of the European invasion of North America in 1620; however, these colonists came to America for different reasons than the empire building Spaniards in New Mexico or the entrepreneurial English in Virginia. Like Converso Jews in New Spain, Pilgrims sought freedom to practice their beliefs separate from state-sponsored religions. Wanting to rid the Anglican Church of any Catholic trappings, Pilgrims were persecuted in England, sought refuge in Holland, but after ten hard years there, decided to seek a new life in Virginia.
Receiving a land grant from the Virginia Company, they crammed 101 men, women, and children aboard The Mayflower. After a tempestuous crossing and encountering more rough seas off the East Coast, The Mayflower abandoned the goal of Virginia and sought refuge in Cape Cod Bay in December of 1620. On the shores of the bay, “they established themselves in an area almost entirely depopulated by an epidemic that had been introduced by white sea traders and had caused the deaths of great numbers of Indians.”[1] So, the first English colony in the northeastern part of North America came about by accident and took over land already prepared by local Indians, now gone.
The early years proved challenging. William Bradford, governor of the colony for thirty-one years, wrote about that first winter: “that which was most sad and lamentable was, that in 2 or 3 months’ time half of their company died, especially in January; and February, being the depth of winter, and wanting houses and other comforts; being infected with scurvy and other diseases, which this long voyage and their in accommodation condition had brought upon them; so as there died some times 2 or 3 of a day… that of 100 and odd persons, scarce 50 remained.”[2]  Like at Jamestown, exposure, disease, or malnutrition took their toll that first year.
For many of us, the past comes alive at a living history park. Part educational, part entertainment, such places spark the imagination so that we experience as directly as possible how people lived in the past. One of the premier places to relive the past is at Plimouth Plantation overlooking the rocky shores of Cape Cod Bay.
A Wampanoag interpreter in a long house.

Upon arrival, I first went to the Wampanoag Homesite where Native Americans in period costume cooked, made crafts, and told stories. I entered into a smoky cedar long house and heard an interpreter from the nearby tribe of Pokanokets answer questions from visitors crowded inside. He explained that they called this place Patuxet, and then said that “we’re ‘En Deus,’ the People. Not Native Americans or Indians.” A teen aged girl asked what he was sitting on and when he said a bear skin, she shockingly asked “Why did you kill the bear?” He asked her if she liked chicken nuggets or hamburgers. When she replied yes, he said it was the same thing.
At the entrance to the English Village.
I then walked uphill to the 17th Century English village and fort. The experiences of the English settlers provide the basis for recreating how people lived in the colony in 1627. At Plimouth Plantation, the staff pretends to know nothing that happened after 1627, and unlike the interpreters at Colonial Williamsburg, none of them broke character with me. While I was there, I had many long conversations with people from the early years of the English colony in New England.
Tourists in shorts and t-shirts ambled between houses with steeply thatched roofs. Interpreters in broad brimmed felt hats and doublets with ruffled collars and women in bonnets and patched aprons covering long skirts talked with the visitors. I heard a Pilgrim soldier ask for volunteers to do a pike drill, and I pushed through the circle of tourists to join in. 
Along with eight other visitors, I hefted a ten-foot long sharpened wooden pike, practiced setting it at an angle, and then balancing it back upright. Our Captain Miles Standish ordered us to march, wheel in line, lower our pikes, and charge the crowd who nervously scattered until Standish yelled “Halt.” He lectured us on the “military arts.” Musketeers and pike men moved together. The marksmen shot their muskets and retreated while the pike men closed with the enemy. As on all the American frontiers, bullets and gun powder were scarce so lances, pikes, swords, and knives often proved more useful in combat.
Above, Capt. Miles Standish asking for volunteers. Below, setting the pike.
 After drilling, I listened to a young visitor talk tactics with Captain Standish who said that some of the local “natural men” were allies while others you had to fight.  For him, it came down to food. Neither side won decisive victories, so each would attack the others’ fields and crops. Combat in early America involved total warfare where warriors attacked their enemy’s ability to sustain a conflict.
As I walked down the dusty lane, Standish’s lieutenant, John Alden the cooper, stopped me: “Are you thinking of settling here yourself?” I replied that I was not sure. He then mentioned that if I was interested, I could do it in one of two ways. I could already have everything that I needed for home and field, or I could commit to working for the company for seven years. I replied: “As attractive as that seemed, I will have to think about it.”
I continued down the main lane past bedding hung on fences to air out. I entered the dim interior of a Pilgrim’s clapboard house where a young woman sat at a table on a hard packed dirt floor. She talked about the struggling colony where the joint stock company owned all their houses. After working for the company for seven years, one could get 100 acres which equaled one share. Her family has eight shares. The colonists sent salted cod fish, furs traded from the “natural people,” lumber, and sassafras to England. They used money from these shipments to pay back the original investment in the colony and to buy items like salt, olive oil, pepper spices, butter, and sugar from England. They worked six days for the company and then kept the Sabbath.
In the next house that I ducked into, I met Goodwife Julianne Morton, sister to Governor William Bradford. I asked her about her beliefs. She mentioned that half of the settlers had no problem with the English church. But “the rest of us wouldn’t be here if we had to go to the King’s Church. Since we’re Separatists, we can be imprisoned and even killed in England.” At Plymouth, they established the Church of God of New Plimouth: “We are anti-Rome and worship no saints, no idols, no stained glass. We are from Bible. Since we are Separatists, the King thinks of us more like a fishing village. We are expanding his kingdom so he overlooks our faith.”
            At the next cottage, I sat down with Patience, the daughter of Jonathan Brewster. Her father left college to serve Queen Elizabeth and even though he was never ordained, the Pilgrims had a friend in the court. She did admit that it was “not quite yet good. No comforts here. It was goodly for us to practice here.”
Goodwife Patience
While we were discussing religion, a visitor entered the room and asked: “Are you a historian?” Patience replied: “No I’m a housewife good lady.” The visitor shook her head as she realized that we were in 1627 and not the 21st century. She then spoke louder and slower. After she left, I asked Patience: “Did you notice? She talked to you like you didn’t know the King’s English.” She gave me a knowing look and then replied: “People react in mysterious ways.”
Some of the interpreters portrayed discontent. Mary said about the first winter: “I have never been to hell but I suspect it was like that -- only hotter.” She continued: “It is horrid here since we have to do everything, and there is no city around.” Some children came into the room, and she asked them if they butcher their own chicken or if their mother does that for them. They quickly left. I then asked Mary if she is single. She said: “I knows all the available men and am not interested.” No city lights and few attractive men perhaps stoked her disgruntlement.
Mary
As I was ending my visit, I bumped into Governor Bradford and his wife on the dusty lane. I asked him about the colony’s relationship with the local Native Americans. He replied that “natural people are fractious. It is like dealing with many kings, like in Germany.” He did admit that he has good relations with his allies. In fact, the neighboring Wampanoag tribe offered the Pilgrims vital assistance, especially the English speaking Squanto who showed the Europeans how to grow corn and reap the bounty of nearby nature. (Even though Pilgrims and Wampanoags did celebrate a harvest festival together in 1621, our national holiday of Thanksgiving did not come about until the Civil War.)
Gov. Bradford and his wife
I enjoyed the long conversations from 1627 that I had with Pilgrims at Plimouth Planation. We discussed religion, England and the King, agriculture and corn cultivation, Separatists, Plymouth, and Native Americans. They transported me back to a time when Europeans started becoming Americans, to the harsh and heady early years of the colonial experience.
Plymouth’s colony never rose above 7,000 Pilgrims, and within a decade, the Puritans to the north subsumed the Separatists. By the 1640s, 16,000 Puritan men and women had migrated to Massachusetts. Sometimes, whole villages in England followed their preacher to New England. Unlike Pilgrims, Puritans wanted at first to merely reform the Church of England, not separate from it. The Puritans established self-governing churches ruled by “saints,” who lived a devout Christian life in God’s grace as opposed to “strangers,” those not yet so blessed. 
To stay blessed, Puritans adhered to the Bible and faced the sinful world. Spirits in many shapes infused the Puritan world. Minister Cotton Mather wrote about the evil that surrounded the blessed: “The devils are so many that some thousands can sometimes at once apply themselves to vex one child of man… They swarm about us, like the frogs of Egypt….”[3]
Because the Puritans had self-governing churches, they became known as Congregationalists. The Puritan ethos continued to shape the colonies and then the United States even up to today. As historian Perry Miller wrote: “While Puritanism could not claim to have single-handedly shaped the American conscience, it certainly helped define its most distinctive traits.”[4] Puritans still influence our national identity and beliefs.
Freedom for Puritans to practice their faith in New England did not bred religious tolerance. Those who pursued the one true religion targeted dissenters. Take Quakers for example. An inner light rose from their prayers which sometimes led to quaking in their limbs, thus Quakers. To Puritans, such jerking bespoke of diabolical possession. Under Puritan dominance, Quakers militantly avowed their religion, sometimes paying for their beliefs with their lives. Some Quaker women ran naked or partially clad through streets, disrupting Puritan life and even church services.[5]
Like colonies in New Mexico and Virginia, Massachusetts at times fought with the natural people. Native Americans and Puritans assaulted each other’s villages, each replied in kind, and atrocities happened. South of Plymouth in 1636, a battle between Puritans and Pequots erupted over an alleged attack on Europeans. Allied with the Mohicans and Narraganset Indians of Rhode Island, Puritans attacked the Pequot town on the Mystic River and set fire to the place. Around 500 Pequots perished in the attack, and Indian allies of the Puritans were shocked by the English ferocity in slaughtering women and children.
Plymouth and Jamestown, Pilgrim Separatists and Anglican entrepreneurs, are the two poles of the British colonial experience. While most of us recognize the solid foundation of Puritanical values and beliefs that come from Massachusetts, perhaps the more free-wheeling expansive spirit of Virginia and the cash crops of tobacco and then cotton represented the future of the nascent nation even better.
Other Christian denominations settled in North America. The Dutch took Manhattan Island in 1629, the French went into Maryland in 1634, a splinter group of Puritans fled Massachusetts for Rhode Island in 1636, Swedes claimed Delaware in 1638, and Quakers settled in Pennsylvania in 1680. All these brought distinctive beliefs to this continent which shaped their subsequent colonial experiences as well as influenced their dealings with Native Americans. 
At all these frontier encounters, European expansion from their colonial beachheads created a profound exchange between native and Christian civilizations and cultures. The Columbian Exchange of foods, beliefs, and technologies impacted people from the Americas to Europe, Africa, and Asia. In fact, the first “shot heard around the world” did not occur at Lexington. The world heard echoes of the first shot that Columbus’ crew fired in 1492. The European colonization of the Western Hemisphere was the first American revolution that shocked the world. We now drive to the French colonial efforts in North American.

Originally created as a not-for-profit museum and park in 1947, Plimouth Plantation now includes a Wampanoag Homesite, a 17th century English village at the main location, and a replica of The Mayflower and the Plimouth Grist Mill in the town of Plymouth. 


All materials in this blog are copyrighted © 2020 by Jon Hunner.

No comments:

Post a Comment