Tuesday, April 7, 2020

Exit 10 – A Fork in the Road: Slavery


Engraved on the Ancestral Chamber at the African Burial Ground NM
           Tucked tightly into a corner of downtown Manhattan, dwarfed by massive federal sky scrapers, the African Burial Ground National Monument pays tribute to the millions of slaves that lived in not just New York, but throughout the country. Placed under seven burial mounds on a third of an acre, remains of 419 Africans and African-Americans pay tribute to those slaves and slave descendants who helped build this country. Thousands more lay beneath the busy streets of this part of Manhattan. In fact, between 15,000 and 20,000 people of African descent were buried in a six-acre area near today’s City Hall – a result of New York City having the second highest number of slaves in the British colonies in the 1700s.
Before such settlement, Native Americans had long lived in the region. Wappingers and Mahicans hunted, fished and farmed in the area between the Delaware and Hudson Rivers. With some local variations, they were similar to the Powhatan of Virginia. As with Native Americans elsewhere, they managed their natural resources well. Europeans who arrived on the East Coast often marveled at the abundance of game and fish in this “wilderness.” This abundance came from the care that Native Americans took to avoid over-exploitation of their regions.
            Europeans first landed in New York in the 16th century. Giovanni da Verrazano and his crew visited this extraordinary natural harbor in 1524. In 1609, Henry Hudson claimed it for the Dutch, who established the New Amsterdam colony in 1624. In 1626, Peter Minuit purchased Manhattan Island from the Manhattes, one of the Wappinger tribes, for sixty guilders (around $24) in trade goods. They built Fort Amsterdam on its southern tip to support the Dutch West India Company’s fur trade operations in the Hudson River watershed. Since Indians considered the earth a deity, humans had no right to own part of a god. For them, selling land to the Dutch was a nifty scam.
            As mentioned in the chapter on colonial Jamestown, twenty slaves from Africa landed in Virginia in 1619. In 1626, a Dutch West India Company’s ship unloaded eleven slaves at New Amsterdam; however, some of the Dutch settlers opposed slavery, so there was little private ownership of humans. Instead slaves worked for the Dutch West India Company on infrastructure projects like repairing the fort, splitting logs for palisades, clearing land, cooking lime for plaster, building docks and roads, and growing and harvesting grain and other crops. These slaves laid the foundation for a viable colony.
            Many of the earliest Muslims came to the shores of North America as slaves. Around 20% of people captured in Sub-Saharan Africa and sent to the colonies were Muslims. Torn from their mosques and imams in Africa, these slaves adapted to the inability to practice Islam by syncretizing their religion.[1]
Portrait of Yarrow Mamout by James Alexander Simpson, 1822. (From exhibit at the National Portrait Gallery, Washington, D.C.)
             Yarrow Mamout serves as an example. Born in Guinea, at 16 he was captured, shipped,  and then sold in Maryland where he was a slave for forty-four years. After he gained his freedom, he lived in Washington, D.C. and made bricks and charcoal, loaded ships, and wove blankets. A painting of Mamout in the National Portrait Gallery depicts him as a centenarian who “upon his death was remembered as a pious Muslim and for his industriousness and determination in the face of adversity.”[2]
            Back at the Dutch colony, slaves could gain “half-freedom.” They paid an annual tax and the West India Company could order them to work when needed. Slaves held some rights including bearing arms in times of emergency, marrying in the Dutch Reformed Church in Manhattan, and even owning their own homes.
            In the 1660s, the British challenged Dutch dominance of the cross Atlantic trade. On September 8, 1664, threatened by English soldiers and frigates, Governor Peter Stuyvesant lowered the West India Company’s flag which ended the Dutch colony. Manhattan then changed its name to New York, in honor of the Duke of York.
            Under the English both in New York and Virginia, the colonies faced a fork in the road. Slavery increased in both places. As a center for trade between England, its American colonies (including Caribbean sugar plantations), and Africa, New York transshipped slaves, sugar, and sterling in a profitable exchange of goods and peoples. Ships delivered slaves to docks north of the Manhattan fort’s palisades which gave rise to a vibrant African community.
The newly arrived English curtailed some of the slaves’ freedoms and allowed harsher types of physical punishments. Then around 1698, the recently built Episcopalian Trinity Church banned African burials in the city’s cemetery. As black neighborhoods thrived north of the fort, a cemetery grew there and eventually expanded to over six acres along the eastern edge of the island.
            Ceremonies at the burial ground resurrected traditional rites from Africa. Wrapped in shrouds and placed in wooden coffins, some bodies had coins over their eyes (for payment of passage through the afterlife) while others had shells, glass beads, or buttons placed on them. They were buried with their heads pointing west, similar to the practice in Africa. Rev. John Sharpe in 1713 wrote: “They are buried in Common by those of their country and complexion without the office; on the contrary the Heathenish rites are performed at the grave by their countrymen.”[3] On my visit, Ranger Cyrus said these burials returned to their African roots with drums, singing, dancing, more like a celebration of the person and not solemn occasions.
            As New York grew, so did the population of slaves. In 1664, when the English took over, New Amsterdam had around 1,500 white settlers, 300 hundred slaves, and 75 freedmen. The 1703 census counted 4,400 whites and between 600 and 700 slaves, and in 1746, the city had a population of 11,720 which included 2,440 slaves, about twenty percent of all residents. By then, perhaps half of the city’s households had at least one slave.[4] In all the English colonies in North America, only Charleston, South Carolina had more slaves than New York City.
As England incorporated the great port city of New York into its mercantile economy of sugar, tobacco, rum, and other riches from the Americas, the city’s businesses and farmers turned to slave labor more and more. New York City depended on cheap labor and thus, slavery grew. As historian Niall Ferguson notes, transatlantic trade and migration grew exponentially “as European merchants and settlers exploited rapidly falling transportation costs and the availability of effectively free land in North America, as well as cheap slave labor in West Africa.”[5]
            We often understand slavery as it evolved into the labor force which supported southern plantations; however, in all thirteen English colonies and in Spanish ones as well, some form of slavery existed. In New Mexico, young Native Americans caught in Spanish raids on their pueblos were forced to work in the haciendas until they came of age. In British colonies on the Atlantic coast, the northern ones were the first to officially recognize slavery. In 1641, Massachusetts legalized chattel slavery, as did Connecticut in 1643, Rhode Island in 1652, and New York in 1664. The South came late to legalizing slavery when, in 1664, Maryland declared that all blacks in the colony, all those imported into it, and all their children would be enslaved for life. By the end of that decade, Virginia enacted similar legislation. At the end of the 17th century, African slaves were a legally protected labor force in British North America.[6]
            Slaves worked as both skilled and unskilled laborers. Slaves built the colonies and without them, the colonies would have struggled to thrive. From farm workers harvesting tobacco to blacksmiths pounding out horseshoes, from urban slaves laying pipelines in New York City to those who helped erect the United States Capitol and the White House, slaves helped to build first the colonies and then the Republic.
            Many slaves lived a brutal life. Long hours under a hot sun doing hard field labor, physical as well as sexual abuse, the wrenching separation of wives from husbands, of parents from children, and a lack of food, all contributed to a miserable existence and a legacy of racism that still haunts their descendants and the nation.
            At times, slaves revolts rocked the colonies and even the hint of rebellion brought harsh judgements. In 1741, a fire ravaged New York City, even burning down the governor’s mansion. A rumor spread that slaves had started it to launch a rebellion. Slaves were arrested, tortured, and tried with thirteen convicted and burned at the stake while another seventeen were hanged.[7]
            In 1700, British North America held almost 28,000 slaves. By 1740, that total increased to 150,000, and both cotton plantations and northern merchants and communities reaped economic rewards as slaves worked in fields, in shipbuilding and sail making yards, in iron foundries, in sawmills, at rum distilleries, and a wide variety of other industries and factories. By the Revolutionary War, the population of American slaves had grown to 452,000 – about one-fifth of the entire colonial population.
            While the colonies united to revolt against English rule and create a democracy, slave men and women undercut the call for liberty and equality. The contradiction was obvious to many. Philadelphia doctor Benjamin Rush asked: “Where is the difference between the British Senator who attempts to enslave his fellow subjects in America, by imposing Taxes upon them contrary to Law and Justice, and the American Patriot who reduces his African Brethren to Slavery, contrary to Justice and Humanity?”[8] Despite the Declaration of Independence, not all men were created equal. After the Revolution, New York passed a law for gradual abolition of slavery in 1799, and on July 4, 1827, all slaves were freed in the Empire State. Other northern states followed.
As southern agriculture adapted to the industrial revolution in the 19th century, the cash crop shifted from tobacco to cotton. In 1810, the South produced 200,000 bales of cotton. By the start of the Civil War, feeding the textile mills in New and old England, the South produced 4,000,000 bales. At this fork in the road, slaves became the labor force for this rapid expansion. The contradiction of slavery in a democratic republic, the role of slave labor in the growth of the nation, and the fight for first emancipation and then civil rights will be explored in future chapters.
From the mid-15th century on, the peoples of Europe, Africa, and the Americas transformed the Atlantic world into an economic dynamo based on ships, slaves, New World crops, and manufactured goods. Without slaves, the industries, municipalities, and farms from New York to Georgia would not have prospered as they did. Slaves played a major role in building America.
           
The African Burial Ground National Monument is a recent and complicated addition to the National Park Service. At the site, the General Services Administration (GSA) planned a $276 million, thirty-four story building to house federal offices. In digging the foundation for this building in 1991, remains of over 400 people were uncovered. The skeletons were taken away to Lehman College in the Bronx for conservation and study.
            Protests arose from the African-American community that the remains were not handled with proper respect. Nor was the African-American community consulted on what to do with the remains. As a result of the controversy, GSA regional director William Diamond halted construction at the building site.
Consequently, the GSA set up an advisory committee which moved the remains to Howard University where Dr. Michael L. Blakey served as the burial ground's scientific director. In a decade of scientific research, Dr. Blakey led some seventy forensic scientists, anthropologists, and African-American scholars in studying the skeletons.
Burial mounds of reburied remains in downtown Manhattan.
            On October 3, 2003, the remains of the 419 people were reinterred under seven burial mounds at the site. Dr. Blakely addressed that gathering: “With the project, we knew that we were peeling off layers of obscurity. We were also … realizing that history has political implications of empowerment and disempowerment. That history is not just to be discovered but to be re-discovered, to be corrected, and that African-American history is distorted. Omissions are made in order to create a convenient view of national and white identity at the expense of our understanding of our world and also at the expense of African-American identity.”[9] The discovery and study of these human remains has created a fuller understanding of African-American experience and identity in New York and in the United States.
In conjunction with the burial mounds, the federal government created a monument to the slaves. The monument consists of an Ancestral Chamber and Circle of Diaspora on one-third of an acre outside the Ted Weiss Federal Building. From the busy sidewalk, I entered the monument and walked past the seven burial mounds to the entrance of the Ancestral Chamber. This twenty-four foot high building of African green granite represents the “soaring African spirit.”[10] Once inside the chamber, “the interior recalls a ship’s hold and provides a place for individual contemplation and prayer.” Of the millions of Africans crammed into ships for transport over the Middle Passage, scholars estimate that one in six died from disease, starvation, or poor sanitation.[11]
Ancestral Chamber
 Exiting the Ancestral Chamber, I walked into the Circle of Diaspora. A tribute to the forced removal of Africans from their homelands, this sunken circle also celebrates the “Africans’ unwavering spirit and ability to adapt.”[12] A map of the world is engraved on the granite floor, surrounded by a circular wall with cultural and spiritual images from all the places that Africans dispersed to, both under force and afterwards. During its use as a cemetery in colonial times, as well as now, the African Burial Ground National Monument is a sacred place in the heart of Manhattan. Under the streets of New York City, evidence of the fork in the road which embraced slavery lies buried by both dirt and time’s passages.

The African Burial Ground National Monument was created by Congress on February 27, 2006, and the monument was dedicated in 2007 to commemorate the role of Africans and African-Americans in the histories of New York City and the United States.[13]

Looking up out of the Ancestral Chamber.
European colonies in North America, mainly founded by Spain, England, and France, opened a successful beachhead on this continent. For better and for worse, the Columbian Exchange created many ways to cultural code-switch which impacted not only the people directly involved and those living on the continent, but the world as a whole. For the next almost two hundred years, native peoples adapted to the Europeans who grew new communities. We now take a tour of those national parks where Americans began to fight for their own rights, for their own government, for their own continent, and to create a new national identity. We drive now to the American Revolution with a detour to the French and Indian War.


All materials in this blog are copyrighted © 2020 by Jon Hunner.




[2] Exhibit text for Mamout’s portrait by James Alexander Simpson at the National Portrait Gallery, Washington, D.C., visited August 2018.


[4] Ibid., 126-127.



[7] Jill Lepore, These Truths: A History of the United States (New York: W.W. Norton & Company, 2018), 63-64.

[8] Lepore, These Truths, 92.

[9] Blakely, “Return to the African Burial Grounds,” Archeology Nov. 20, 2003. http://archive.archaeology.org/online/interviews/blakey/

[10] Exhibit text at African Burial Ground NM, visited July 2013.

[11] Sutton, et al, Slavery in the United States, 10.

[12] Exhibit text at African Burial Ground NM, visited July 2013.


[13] African Burial Ground National Monument-- http://www.nps.gov/afbg/index.htm.

No comments:

Post a Comment