Friday, April 10, 2020

Exit 13 – Crafting the Rebellion at Independence National Historical Park, Pennsylvania


 Today, we take for granted that American independence was inevitable; however, at the time, a strenuous debate swept the colonies about whether they should revolt, how to rally the colonial public to support such a rebellion, and what type of government should replace the Parliament’s representatives in North America. All of these heady issues swirled around the British colonies in America, and particularly in Philadelphia. At this place, the intellectual and public justifications for the rebellion flourished. Alongside the debates about rebellion, a growing call for innovation in government, for a democracy, also grew.
As the debates, discussions, and arguments about the rebellion divided people up and down the Atlantic colonies, much of the intellectual fervor centered in Philadelphia. King Charles II granted Pennsylvania to William Penn in 1682. Pennsylvania became a place of religious freedom for Quakers and of tolerance for others. Known as the City of Brotherly Love, Philadelphia with its lively port, its centrality between the north and south colonies, its location as a gateway to productive lands in the west, and its embrace of the many peoples who flocked to its cobbled streets became a epicenter of colonial thought and action during the second half of the 18th century.
            It was one thing for a group of hotheads in Massachusetts to start shooting at the Redcoats. It was something else altogether to establish a unified governing body to justify, fund, and fight a rebellion against the most powerful army in the world. Much of the discussion and planning for this happened in the streets, taverns, and formally in Philadelphia’s Pennsylvania State House, now known as Independence Hall.
Of the many critical moments in the founding of our republic, two essential ones occurred at this State House. First, the Continental Congress drafted and signed the Declaration of Independence in 1776. Second, in 1787-1788, the State House hosted the creation of our Constitution. As a nexus of colonial thought, Philadelphia held a unique role for the rebellion and the nascent republic.
England’s rising belligerence to its American colonies fostered an equal reaction among many colonials. In response to the Intolerable Acts which punished Boston for its Tea Party, Benjamin Franklin called for the First Continental Congress to meet in Philadelphia on September 5, 1774 at Carpenters' Hall. Many of the Founding Fathers came to this Congress, including future presidents George Washington and John Adams.
Carpenters' Hall
The Congress, with representatives from all the North American colonies but Georgia and Canada, petitioned King George to repel these acts and remove British soldiers from Boston. They issued a “Declaration and Resolves of the First Congress” which affirmed loyalty to Great Britain while at the same time declaring “That the foundation of English liberty, and of all free government, is a right in the people to participate in their legislative council.”[1] Although a birthright for English people, political representation did not exist for the colonies. At this stage, popular sentiment rose up against Parliament’s usurpation of their civil rights, but not yet against King  George.
The ruling chair at Carpenters' Hall
The First Continental Congress called for the colonies to boycott British goods if the Intolerable Acts remained in force starting on December 1, 1774. Congress also resolved to reconvene on May 10, 1775 if the King refused to redress their grievances. Then the First Continental Congress disbanded.  King George was not amused.
I arrived at Independence Mall before noon on a muggy August day. At the large Visitors’ Center, I secured one of the last tickets that day for a tour of Independence Hall. I spent several hours looking at paintings of well-known and lesser-known revolutionaries in the Portrait Gallery, entered the rebuilt Declaration House where Thomas Jefferson penned the Declaration, and visited Franklin Court which houses the country’s first post office. There I watched park rangers set type to reprint the Declaration on a hand-operated press. I imagined the debates about rebellion that rang out at City Tavern, at Quaker meetinghouses, and in Carpenter’s Hall. I easily lost myself among the places where history actually happened as I walked the bustling streets of downtown Philadelphia.
Independence Hall
 At the appointed hour, I returned to Independence Hall. NPS Ranger Greg, our tour guide, took us into the hallowed meeting room where the delegates debated and signed the Declaration. Roaming among the delegates’ tables behind a railing, Greg focused on one complaint against England. He cited an interview of Patriot Captain Levi Preston, a Minute Man from Massachusetts. Was it the Stamp Act? Preston replied: “I never saw one of those stamps.” What about the tea-tax? “Tea-tax! I never drank a drop of the stuff; the boys threw it overboard.” Greg then quoted Preston about why he took up arms: “What we meant in going for those Redcoats was this: we always had governed ourselves, and we always meant to. They didn’t mean we should.”[2] Preston and his fellow Patriots rebelled against this denial of self-governance. While lack of representation motivated some, many reasons drove the rebels. Discontent with their colonial status ran wide and deep.
Ranger Greg holding up a copy of the Declaration of Independence.
As explored in the previous exit, fighting erupted near Boston in April 1775. This dramatically altered the Second Continental Congress, which convened on May 19 at Independence Hall. In response to the “Olive Branch Petition” sent to the King proclaiming American loyalty to Britain, George declared  the colonies in open revolt and ordered his army to treat colonials as “open and avowed enemies.” Declaring them dangerous, George lost support from more colonials.
In anticipation of the continuing conflict, the Second Congress created the Continental Army on June 14 and appointed Virginia delegate George Washington as its commander-in-chief. Washington wrote to his wife Martha: “It has been determined in Congress that the whole army raised for the defense of the American cause shall be put under my Care, and that it is necessary for me to proceed immediately to Boston to take upon me the command of it.”[3] 
Congress chose Washington for several reasons. He had held command positions in the French and Indian War. He also came from Virginia, the wealthiest and largest colony. Originally, Washington had been a loyalist; however, by now, he had lost faith with King George and England.
Despite the action of the Continental Congress, a curious flaw existed. It had no legal authority to create an army, to tax, to print money, or to pass legislation. In fact, it had no legal authority to maintain a central government over the separate colonies. The Congress came into its own on its own, created itself out of thin air, and then it began to fight for independence and to figure out how to govern. It was an audacious innovation for a colonial people, a move fraught with uncertainty and peril, a fork in the road which could have led to ruin.
The Continental Congress in the spring of 1776 moved toward a formal declaration of freedom. On May 10, it passed a resolution calling on all colonies to form a revolutionary government, jettisoning the last legal connections with King and Parliament.  John Adams wrote a preamble that set out the call for independence which passed on May 15.
On June 7, Richard Henry Lee of Virginia proposed a resolution that “these United Colonies are, and of right ought to be free and independent states.” A Committee of Five, led by Thomas Jefferson with John Adams, Benjamin Franklin, Roger Sherman, and Robert Livingston, drafted the resolution. The Continental Congress debated the declaration for the rest of that month in a stifling heat wave made worse by the room’s closed shutters to ensure privacy.
In contrast to a government controlled by the royalty and aristocracy of England, the Declaration called for a system of governance where “all people are created equal,” where governments derived their “just Powers from the consent of the people,” and where people needed to “alter or abolish” that government if the unalienable rights of “life, Liberty, and the pursuit of Happiness” were curtailed.
The NPS reconstructed Jefferson's room in Philadelphia where he penned the Declaration of Independence.
In fact, it declared that “when a long train of abuses and usurpations, pursuing invariably the same object evinces a design to reduce them under absolute despotism, it is their right, it is their duty, to throw off such government, and to provide new guards for their future security.”[4] After establishing the natural and legal rights of people to seek freedom and civil rights from an unjust form of government, the rest of the Declaration was a list of twenty-seven specific abuses perpetrated by King George and Parliament against the colonies.
Are there inalienable rights such as all people being created equal? As historian Yuval Noah Harari states: “You always insist that the order sustaining society is an objective reality created by the great gods or by the laws of nature…. People are equal, not because Thomas Jefferson said so, but because God created them that way.”[5] Congress, after creating itself out of thin air, then manifested rights that even its members did not fully support. Equality for non-land owners? For women? For slaves? Demanding freedom from England, Congress extended that cry to equality for all people, something few really supported. For Jefferson, the Declaration “was intended to be an expression of the American mind.”[6]
Fifty-seven representatives from all thirteen colonies signed the Declaration of Independence in the Assembly Room of Independence Hall, including such luminaries as John Adams, Benjamin Franklin, and Thomas Jefferson. The delegates officially ratified the declaration on July 4, 1776, marking  the birth of the United States of America.
To announce the reading of the Declaration on July 8, a bell rang in  Independence Hall tower. Visitors to Independence National Historical Park today wait in long lines to walk past this potent symbol of the basic human right of liberty. One of the most cherished symbols of American Independence, this bell was cast in 1752 at the Whitechapel Bell Foundry in England with the legend “Proclaim LIBERTY throughout all the land unto all the inhabitants thereof.” English liberty has a long tradition, dating back to the Magna Carta. In editions of the popular Poor Richard’s Almanack, Ben Franklin would note for the month of June: “On the 15th of this month, anno 1215, was Magna Charta sign’d by King John, for declaring and establishing English Liberty.”[7]
Although the delegates from the various colonies approved the Declaration, the public needed to support it as well. To help Virginians rally around the call for independence, Patrick Henry gave a rousing speech to the House of Burgess in Richmond. In addressing a key complaint by the colonials – the presence of British soldiers on American Soil—Henry posed:

They are sent over to bind and rivet upon us those chains which the British ministry have been so long forging…. We have done everything that could be done to avert the storm which is now coming on…. Three million of people, armed in the holy cause of liberty … are invincible by any force which our enemy can send against us.[8]

Henry concluded: “I know not what course others may take, but as for me, give me liberty, or give me death.”[9] With such rousing orations, popular support rose for the rebellion. This fork also led to war, death, and destruction.
Threatened by approaching British forces, Congress abandoned Philadelphia and moved to Baltimore in the winter of 1776. After returning, it had to leave again in September 1777 when General William Howe and his Redcoats occupied the City of Brotherly Love. By then, Congress was drafting the “Articles of Confederation and Perpetual Union” which the delegates approved in November 1777. John Dickerson and Benjamin Franklin worked together to create the Articles that established the rules and duties for the national government including prosecuting the war and seeking peace, negotiating diplomatic and trade agreements, and settling disputes between states.
A debate arose concerning the type of national government which pitted populous states against smaller ones, northern against southern states, and those who favored a strong national government against those who wanted strong individual states. Historian Jill Lepore notes that “the final Articles of Confederation are more like a peace treaty, establishing a defensive alliance among sovereign states than a constitution.”[10] In the Confederation, the smaller states won in regards to representation since each state got one vote whatever its population. A fatal difficulty under the Articles arose since the national government did not have power to raise money through taxes. As the Revolutionary War waged across the colonies, the national government struggled to finance the war with borrowed money.
Philadelphia has continued to serve as a vibrant city in the country and is proud of its past as one of the most important birthplaces of the republic. Millions of parkgonauts from around the world have converged on Philadelphia, tramped over the grassy mall, lined up to view the Liberty Bell, toured Independence Hall and the Portrait Gallery, and visited the other sites of this National Historical Park. As such, the area around Independence Hall is sacred ground for modern democracy.

At first, the old State House and the surrounding buildings held little significance for the American people. Then in the 1820s, one room was designated as Independence Hall and the surrounding block as Independence Square. A first floor museum opened in 1876, and the second floor restored in 1897. On June 28, 1948, U.S. Congress authorized the Independence National Historical Park which was formally established on July 4, 1956.[11] Independence Hall became a UNESCO World Heritage Site on October 23, 1979 to recognize the birthplace of modern democracy. 
NPS staff at the Franklin House reprinting the Declaration of Independence.


All materials in this blog are copyrighted © 2020 by Jon Hunner.


[1] Erik Bruun & Jay Crosby, Our Nation’s Archive: The History of the United States in Documents (New York: Black Dog & Leventhal Publishers, 1999), 126-27.

[2] George Brown Tindal & David E. Shi, America: A Narrative History (New York: W.W. Norton & Company, 1996), 233-34.


[4] Bruun & Crosby, Our Nation’s Archive, 129-131.

[5] Yuval Noah Harari, Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind (London: Vintage, 2014), 126.

[6] Jill Lepore, These Truths: A History of the United States (New York: W.W. Norton & Company, 2018), 98.

[7] Ibid., 66.

[8] Bruun and Crosby, Our Nation’s Archive, 118-19.

[9] Ibid., 119

[10] Lepore, These Truths, 97-98.


[11] Independence National Historical Park-- http://www.nps.gov/inde/index.htm

No comments:

Post a Comment