Saturday, April 4, 2020

Exit 7 – The English at Colonial National Historical Park and Colonial Williamsburg, Virginia




On May 13, 1607, three wooden sailing ships tied up off the shore of Virginia. The Susan Constant, the Godspeed, and the Discovery had left London on December 20 and after provisioning stops at the Canary and Caribbean Islands, arrived in Virginia at the end of April. The three ships then sailed up and down the James River searching for a suitable site for a colony. It had to be far enough up-river to avoid detection by the Spanish, easily defended, and the river just off the island had to be thirty-six feet deep so that ships could moor directly onto shore. At Jamestown Island, 102 men and boys disembarked to establish Jamestown, the first permanent English settlement in North America.

Replica of Godspeed at Jamestown Settlement.
 The English came late in the colonial rush to the Americas and then failed early attempts to establish a colony.  In the late 1580s, they tried several times in North Carolina at Roanoke. While there, they named the land Virginia, after Queen Elizabeth I (the Virgin Queen) who supported their efforts. Her successor, James I, granted a charter to the Virginia Company to settle the east coast. As a private business, the Virginia Company had profit as its main purpose. The charter created two branches—the Virginia Companies of London and of Plymouth. The London branch founded the Jamestown colony, while the Plymouth one later established itself north of Virginia.
The men and boys in 1607 faced a daunting challenge. They had to establish a viable community at great distance from England amid the Algonquin who resisted settlement, and at a place picked for its defensive qualities but inherently unhealthy. Nearby swamps bred mosquitos and disease. Brackish water sickened colonists. Within six months of first landing, fifty percent of the colonists had died from disease as well as conflict with the Powhatans.
The colonists built a triangular Fort James on the banks of the river that measured 100 yards by 100 yards by 150 yards. At the corners of this log-palisaded compound, artillery protected approaches to the fort. Within this small enclosure, the future of English colonization in North America rested. 
Bronze model of Fort James overlooking the James River.
Inside, settlers adapted to life at the end of the world. They sought ways to make money by utilizing the abundant surrounding resources. Artifacts excavated from an early well on display at the site illustrate their attempts at brewing, silk production, brick making, blacksmithing, collecting medicinal plants, and glassblowing. For example, in 1608, German and Polish glassblowers arrived to use the large amounts of sand for glass and wood as fuel to make window glass and bottles for export to London. This and other early experiments failed to turn a profit. Also within the compound, Reverend Bucke conducted the first Church of England service under a billowing sailcloth in May 1607.
In 1608, the “Second Supply” from England arrived on three ships which brought another 100 or so men and boys, plus two women. The colony struggled through the winter and survived another year; however, the resupply of the summer of 1609 went tragically awry. Nine ships set sail from England but a hurricane caught them on open seas, and the one with the leaders for the colony wintered in Bermuda.
At Fort James, the “Starving Time” gripped the colony, and cannibalism prowled through the community. In April 2012, the remains of a fourteen-year old girl nicknamed Jane were uncovered and analyzed by forensic archeologists at Jamestown. She had died during the Starving Time. The resident research center, Jamestown Rediscovery, announced in May 2013 that “Jane’s Remains” showed evidence of cannibalism with cut marks on bones and a hole in the skull.[1] When I visited, her skeleton was chillingly displayed behind plexiglass. At the beginning of the winter of 1609-1610, around 400 people lived at the fort. By the end of next spring, only sixty survived. 
Graveyard inside Fort James.
In the spring of 1610, the remaining few settlers abandoned Fort James and set sail for England. Downtown river from the settlement, they met the long delayed supply ships and turned around. Imagine the emotions of survivors of the Starving Time as they returned to the site of so much suffering.
Jamestown quickly resettled, but the question of how to make profit hung heavy over the Virginia Colony. They had to find something of value to satisfy financial backers in England, or Jamestown would fail. While the crown supported settlement in principal, it gave no money for the expensive undertakings of colonization.
Enter John Rolfe. He arrived on the Third Supply in May 1610, having spent the winter on the Bermuda Islands where his wife and daughter had died. While in Bermuda, he secured tobacco seeds which came from the Spanish colonies. Tobacco, imported by the Spanish, had filled that country’s treasury as smoking swept Europe. In 1611, Rolfe started cultivating the sweeter tobacco of the Caribbean on Virginian soil and in 1612, sent four hogshead barrels of the golden leaf to England which sold out quickly. This powerful drug started to turn a profit and helped make Jamestown permanent.
A field of tobacco growing at Jamestown Settlement.
We now return to Pocahontas. As daughter of Wahunsenaca, the paramount chief of the Powhatan, she met the English soon after they arrived. During the winter of 1607-08, the Powhatan captured Capt. John Smith and brought him to their capital across the York River from the James Peninsula. Legend has it that Pocahontas (who was eleven or twelve at the time and the chief’s favorite daughter) saved Smith’s life by placing her head over his as it was about to be smashed. Whether the Powhatans truly sought to kill Smith or whether this was an elaborate ceremony of acceptance, Smith became an adopted son of the Wahunsenaca.
Pocahontas eventually married John Rolfe in April 1614, and the “Pocahontas’ Peace” halted the fighting between the Powhatan and the English. This peaceful period of about a decade allowed the colony to expand into other parts of the coastal plains. Then on a tour of England with Rolfe and their son Thomas, Pocahontas died. Back in the colony, Rolfe remarried, but died on his plantation in 1622.
Pocahontas’ Peace ended that year as attacks by Powhatans killed some 350 to 400 of the 1,200 settlers. Fighting between the two cultures continued for ten years, until a fragile peace was signed in 1632. A final attack occurred in 1644 when another 350 to 400 of the then 8,000 settlers died. A peace treaty in 1646 officially ended conflict. The Algonquin continued to live in the East Coast, even to this day, but after the mid-1600s, their civilization waned, eclipsed by the English, by their technologies, their draft animals, their diseases, and their commerce and trade networks with Europe and the Caribbean.
In 1619, a significant moment in self-government occurred in the colony. At the end of July, a General Assembly met at Jamestown church. Eleven main regions of the colony sent two representatives each to debate how to create a governing body. Although hampered by a heat wave, Governor Yeardley on July 30, 1619 called for the creation of the House of Burgesses. It has met continuously since, is now known as the Virginia General Assembly, and is the oldest continuous assembly of representative government in the Western Hemisphere.
That year, two other developments changed the colony. First, twenty African slaves (Kimbundu speakers from Ndongo) landed at Jamestown, and  they grew in importance, especially after Bacon’s Rebellion. Additionally, the Virginia Company sent ninety women to Virginia, so after 1619, families gained importance for the colony’s permanence. As Virginia gained stability with the influx of settlers and slaves, with the support of the crown, and through treaties with the Powhatan, it grew into a thriving colony by the middle of the 17th century.
Nonetheless, as Virginia grew, problems simmered. Adverse weather harmed crops. Indentured servants who agreed to serve in exchange for passage to Virginia and room and board also contributed to the discontent. Once servants completed their indenture, they had little to support themselves. Finally, some nearby tribes attacked outlying plantations which often were established by indentured servants now free. For colonists who wanted scapegoats, Indians became an easy target.
The spark that ignited Bacon’s Rebellion in 1675 started with an attack by Doeg Indians. In response to the outbreak of hostilities, Nathaniel Bacon, a recent arrival to the colony, organized close to 1,000 settlers to retaliate. Virginia’s Governor William Berkeley gave Bacon official permission to attack the Doeg, but this unleashed an indiscriminate hunt for any Indians. Then the frontier war turned into a civil war as Berkeley attacked Bacon, who in response occupied and set fire to Jamestown. As the colony reeled in turmoil, Bacon died of the “bloody flux” (possibly cholera or dysentery), and the rebellion fizzled out.
This struggle revealed several underlying challenges for the colony. First, how to live in peace with the nearby Native Americans? And second, how to supply the necessary labor for the intensive work in the tobacco fields? The indentured servant system had helped fuel the crisis since many of Bacon’s followers were discontented freemen. These two issues would impact not just Virginia’s future, but that of the rest of North America.
Although Africans had arrived as slaves in Jamestown in 1619, they were not a large part of the workforce. After Bacon’s Rebellion, plantation owners begin to view slaves as an attractive alternative to indentured servants. With slaves, the workforce lasted a lifetime, any children from slave couples belonged to the owner, and harsher punishments were used to enforce obedience. So in the aftermath of Bacon’s Rebellion, Virginia and the other tobacco producing colonies began to rely more on African slaves. To explore the issue of slavery more, we will visit the African Burial Grounds in New York City at the end of this section.
Fire roared through Jamestown in 1698, and as a result, the capitol moved to Middle Plantation, soon renamed Williamsburg. As settlers spread out over the coastal plains and into the Blue Ridge Mountains and as other English colonies attracted new immigrants, Jamestown faded away. We now drive up Colonial Highway to nearby Williamsburg.
“Colonial Williamsburg” stands out as a premier living history park where costumed interpreters role play living in the years right before the American Revolution. I looked for staff pretending to be living in 1774 and hailed a man in costume striding along the Duke of Gloucester Street. He turned out to be Revolutionary War hero General Knox. I asked him where the first person interpreters were, and he admitted that if I hadn’t asked him that question, he would have responded to me from 1774. He said that the interpreters at Colonial Williamsburg balance staying in character with hospitality and with me, he chose to talk to me in the present time. He also said that a group of African American interpreters were portraying slaves just down the street.
I found five African American interpreters sitting on a bench nearby talking about freedom and liberty. Benjamin, a slave of Mr. Witt’s, said: “If Mr. Witt stood on these steps and said ‘freedom for all,’ he’d get cheered. If I stood and said ‘freedom for all,’ I’d get jeered.” Jacob, another slave, looked around and said: “These beautiful buildings were built by slaves. How can you trust a man who talks about freedom but owns slaves?” By the American Revolution, slavery comprised over half of the population of Virginia. 
At one point, one of the slaves started crying and went to blow his nose on the Dallas Cowboys shirt of a visitor, saying that is an ugly shirt. I later confirmed that the interpreter was a Washington Redskins fan. Living history takes many forms.
Interpreters portraying slaves talking with a Dallas Cowboys fan at Colonial Williamsburg.
 Down the street, General Knox was extorting a crowd with cries for freedom and the need to fight against the tyranny of England. Overhearing this, Jacob commented: “In 1772, England banned slavery so are these white men going to war against taxes or afraid that they’ll lose their slaves?” Benjamin chimed in: “A man can’t love freedom and slaves at the same time. It is not a fight for freedom.” Jacob agreed: “It’s a fight for oppression.”
In an outbuilding of the Peyton Randolph House, I spent time with Robert, a slave candle maker. Like other interpreters at Colonial Williamsburg, he switched from 1774 to the present in our conversation. While demonstrating how he dipped candles in hot wax, we talked about civil rights since the Revolution. He said: “After the Civil War, a new slavery kicked in—sharecropping. It kept folks in servitude forever in the United States.” Robert continued: “Abraham Lincoln freed the Negros but the U.S. didn’t give them civil rights.” He concluded: “We still got a lot of work to do.”
Robert making candles at Colonial Williamsburg.
These two sites offer an in-depth presentation of colonial Virginia through preservation and innovative interpretation. As the first permanent English colony in the United States, Jamestown offers a contrast to the other settlement that came from the Virginia Company, that of Plymouth in New England. Many people think of Plymouth and the pilgrims before Jamestown (even though the Virginians arrived thirteen years earlier). The puritanical pilgrims portrayed with stout faith, dour demeanors, and intense industriousness are compared to the more care-free Virginians; however, the entrepreneurial spirit (based on the cultivation of the drug tobacco) and the carpe diem attitude (from the early days where death took away family and friends) of the Virginians are founding characteristics of Americans. The colonies of Jamestown and Plymouth offer us contrasting models of the American experience. So let’s now drive up the coast to Plimouth Plantation.

The Association for the Preservation of Virginia Antiquities (now Preservation Virginia), founded in 1889, received the Jamestown church ruins and twenty-two surrounding acres in 1893 from Mr. and Mrs. Edward Barney.  In 1934, the National Park Service acquired the remaining 1,500 acres of Jamestown Island. Historic Jamestowne has been jointly managed by the APVA/Preservation Virginia and the National Park Service ever since. John D. Rockefeller began buying parts of Williamsburg in the 1930s and reconstructing it as a living history park.[2]


Fort James today.

All materials in this blog are copyrighted © 2020 by Jon Hunner.



[2] Colonial National Historical Park-- http://www.nps.gov/jame/index.htm; Colonial Williamsburg-- www.history.org/index.cfm.

1 comment:

  1. Jon, this is very interesting. I visited Colonial Williamsburg in the 1970s. They had costumed folks at the various display places, but I do not recall interpreters like you describe.Mostly interpretation occurred at presentations within places, like the book bindery, for instance. We did not get to Jamestown, but I'm not sure it was as developed at that time.
    Cheers!
    Fenton

    ReplyDelete