Thursday, April 30, 2020

Exit 33 – The Fight for the West at Shiloh National Battlefield, Tennessee


 After the Confederate victory at Manassas, both sides in the East hunkered down for the winter, recruited and trained new soldiers, and sought ways to implement their overall strategies. We now focus on the Union’s western campaign into the South and turn to one of “the fiercest battle yet seen in the Civil War, indeed one of the fiercest to be fought until the coming of mass warfare on the Western Front fifty years later.”[1]
            Dense woodlands of the South hindered overland travel. The thick forests slowed foot and wagon passage and prevented rapid movement of large numbers of soldiers and materiel. The major rivers that coursed through the South -- the Mississippi, the Tennessee, the Cumberland, and the Ohio -- opened up wide avenues for transportation and for invasion. River travel became so important in this theater that the Union leased almost 150 steamboats to prosecute the war.
Tennessee River system. (From exhibit at Corinth unit of Shiloh NB)
The Union pried open the Tennessee River in February 1862 when General Ulysses S. Grant’s army captured Forts Henry and Donelson and forced Southern troops to abandon northwestern Tennessee. Once those forts fell, Union troops steamed upriver to Pittsburg Landing, about thirty miles north of the border and Corinth, Mississippi. Corinth, a key railroad junction, connected the Deep South with its northern and western states and proved a prime target for the Union in conquering the Confederacy.
Gen. Grant. (From exhibit at Shiloh NB)
            The Union leader of this campaign was Grant, a West Point graduate who had fought gallantly in the Mexican American War but boredom with the peacetime Army compounded by drink led to his resignation from the military. Once the Civil War started, he took over organizing supplies for troops from his home state of Ohio and then led soldiers from that state. At Fort Henry, U. S. Grant earned the nickname “Unconditional Surrender” when he replied to the Confederate general’s inquiry about terms of capitulation. By Shiloh, he commanded 40,000 soldiers from the region.
Gen. Johnston. (From exhibit at Shiloh NB)
Confederate General Albert Sidney Johnston opposed Grant at Shiloh. Also a veteran of the Mexican War, he was widely regarded as the best military leader in the Confederacy and took command of the western theater. He marched his 44,000 men north from Corinth to force the issue on open ground around the small Shiloh Church, near the Union’s beachhead at Pittsburg Landing.
Grant had orders not to engage the enemy until General Don Carlos Buell’s troops coming from Nashville joined him. But on April 6, a Union dawn patrol encountered a Confederate picket line around 5 a.m. They exchanged gunfire for an hour, and then General Johnston launched his Army of the Mississippi against the Union forces. For the rest of the morning, rebel troops pushed back the Northerners’ three-mile wide front in vicious fighting.
Confederate advance first day of battle. (From exhibit at Shiloh NB)
I rode my bike on the loop from the initial contact amid the woods to the Hornet’s Nest (so named for the buzz of bullets flying through the air) in the center of the Union line. There, Union soldiers defended against at least three assaults. After six hours of intense and bloody combat, Northerners still held the dense oak thicket at the center of the battlefield. Confederates brought artillery from other parts of the battlefield and pounded the Hornet’s Nest into submission from 300 yards away. Over 2,000 Union soldiers surrendered due to “the Confederates [concentrating on them] the greatest collection of artillery yet to appear on the American Continent.”[2]
Massed cannons aimed at the Hornet's Nest.
After capturing the Hornet’s Nest, Johnston’s forces advanced, threatening the Union base at Pittsburg Landing. Northern soldiers staggered back to earthworks around the landing all afternoon and aided by a heavily wooded ravine in front of them, held their position as the day ended. Johnston and his staff predicted an easy victory the next day. Grant’s assessment of the battle? “Whip ‘em tomorrow.”[3]
That night, the battle turned against the men in gray as advance units of Buell’s Army of the Ohio ferried across the Tennessee River and joined the defenses of Pittsburg Landing. More than 20,000 Northerners crossed the river as the USS Lexington and the USS Tyler, two Union paddlewheel gunboats, bombarded nearby Confederates.
Union gunboat Lexington. (From exhibit at Shiloh NB)
On April 7, Grant’s and Buell’s Divisions attacked the Confederates and drove them back. Rain pelted troops and as the fighting raged over the same terrain as the previous day, soldiers stepped over the dead and the wounded who had suffered through the bitter night. Little aid was given as combat swirled around them, and more died in the rain. At the height of the combat, 60,000 men fought each other over an eight square mile battlefield.
Rallying his troops near the frontline, Johnston was struck by a bullet which severed his femoral artery, and he bled to death in a matter of minutes. Thus fell the highest ranking officer from either side during the entire Civil War. Beauregard, who had already distinguished himself at Fort Sumter and at First Manassas, took over command of the Confederates. Pressed by fresh Union troops, around 4 p.m. Beauregard ordered his troops to leave the field. They retreated to Corinth.
Over the thirty-four-hour battle, a total of 23,746 men were killed, wounded, or missing. Both sides suffered greatly but “the battle mutilated the western army of the Confederacy, which lost key officers, 10,000 men, and perhaps its best opportunity to destroy a Union army in the field.”[4] Unlike in the eastern theater, the tide turned for the North in the west.
Map of Railroads during Civil War. (From exhibit at Corinth unit)
The battered Union army trailed behind the Confederates to the railroad town of Corinth, Mississippi for a final reckoning. Two of the most important railroads in the Confederacy crossed at Corinth—the Memphis & Charleston and the Mobile & Ohio. They linked the Mississippi River to the Atlantic seaboard and the Gulf Coast to Kentucky. This made Corinth the most strategic transportation hub in the western part of the Confederate states. Under siege from April 29 to May 30, Confederate troops built several miles of rifle pits, trenches, and earthworks around the small town. Despite these defensive strongholds, at the end of May Beauregard and his troops abandoned Corinth. For this, he lost his command.
Union forces first under Generals Henry Halleck and then William Rosecrans fortified Corinth and eventually dug additional trenches, an inner line of defense. Confederates returned at the beginning of October to try to retake the town. After the battle, one observer said: “In places, you could walk on the dead.” This intense assault by Confederates through the town and onto the earthworks failed with 8,000 men from both sides killed, wounded, or missing.
Minnie balls and ammunition pouch. (From exhibit at Shiloh NB)
Various types of artillery shells. (From exhibit at Manassas NB)
Soldiers required special care from the devastation that minnié ball bullets and artillery shells wrecked on the human body. To care for the wounded, each regiment of 200-300 soldiers had a surgeon, an assistant surgeon, and a hospital steward. During battle, the number of wounded often overwhelmed the surgeons, who treated them just behind the front lines. Triage was fast. Soldiers with minor wounds underwent dressing and then returned to combat. Those more seriously wounded were evacuated to a field hospital further away from the battle, often a barn or residence.
Shattered limbs had little chance of healing as the many splinters of bone and open wounds proved difficult to treat. Amputation was rapid, partially because the ether or chloroform wore off quickly and partially because new casualties arrived constantly. Without antibiotics, gangrene from a wound could set in and kill a patient. If a soldier survived the cutting off of a limb, they still could succumb to complications like gangrene or pneumonia.
At Shiloh, medical officers from both armies cared for 16,420 wounded men. Once stabilized, most of the 8,408 Union wounded went by steamboat to Savannah, Tennessee. Many of the Confederate wounded first went to Corinth and then by railroad to other towns and cities in the western Confederacy. At Corinth, almost every building served as a hospital to care for the men. Churches, aid societies, and soldiers’ families rushed medical supplies and people to help. As with most Civil War battles, nearby towns served as hospitals for months afterward, and the stench of death wafted over communities.
Wounded waiting for care. Taken in Virginia in 1862. (From exhibit at Shiloh NB)
One of those who heeded the call for help was Kate Cumming, whose brother fought at Shiloh. She wrote in her journal: “Corinth is more unhealthy than ever. The cars have just come in, loaded outside and inside with troops…they have endured all kinds of hardships; going many days with nothing but parched corn to eat….” Another entry from her: “I have been through the ward to see if the men are in want of anything; but all are sound asleep under the influence of morphine. Much of that is administered; more than for their good…. I expressed this opinion to one of the doctors; he smiled, and said it was not as bad as to let them suffer.”[5]
Kate Cumming. (From exhibit at Shiloh NB)
Kate also wrote: “There is a Mr. Pinkerton from Georgia shot through the head. A curtain is drawn across a corner where he is lying to hide the hideous spectacle, as his brains are oozing out.”[6] Before medical colleges, before the American Medical Association, before modern battlefield medicine, treatment of combat wounds remained basic—amputation the main choice, and wounds considered non-lethal today could often led to a man’s death. As Keegan writes: “it was a lucky victim of a minié strike who was not killed outright or left with a permanently disabling wound. Shiloh was the first battle of the war that exhibited these effects on a large scale.”[7] Surgeons, soldiers, and officers all learned how to improvise in this new war.
Diagram of Field Tent Hospital. (From exhibit at Shiloh NB)
At the same time as the attack on Corinth in October 1862, Confederate soldiers under General Bragg marched through Kentucky toward Cincinnati, at the time a more important industrial and railroad center than Chicago. If the South crossed the Ohio River and captured Cincinnati, they could accomplish what Grant was trying to do to the Confederacy. Bragg’s invasion failed at the Battle of Perryville. As Keegan explains about the defeats at Corinth and Perryville: “the failure in the West was a grave blow to the Confederacy….”[8] The failures of the South to win battles in its west opened up the region to further invasion by the North.
After May 1862, some slaves who had fled their plantations found refuge in Corinth. Called “contrabands of war,” some 6,000 African American ex-slaves created a thriving community of homes, a church and school, a hospital, and a cooperative farm. From the Corinth Contraband Camp, nearly 2,000 ex-slaves enlisted in the Union’s First Alabama Regiment of African Descent to join over 150,000 Blacks who fought in the Civil War.
Family in front of cabin at Corinth contraband camp. (From exhibit at Corinth unit)

African American soldiers. (From exhibit at Corinth unit)
Several important lessons came from Shiloh. Grant learned that the Civil War would not be won by one decisive battle—that it was a war of attrition “in which casualties would be equally distributed and the decision would be won by the army best able to bear the agony.”[9] This shaped Grant’s ruthless engagements in the future and endeared him to Lincoln. When criticism of Grant reached the president, he replied: “I can’t spare this man: he fights.”[10]

The battle at Shiloh Church and the subsequent siege and occupation of Corinth shifted the war in the West. Vital transportation and communication lines were severed from the Confederacy, and paths to both Chattanooga on the Tennessee River and Vicksburg on the Mississippi River lay open to Grant and his forces. If the Union could crack Chattanooga and Vicksburg, the South would open up like a shelled pecan. But both proved to be tough nuts to crack.

Shiloh became a National Military Park in 1894 managed by the Department of War and was transferred to the National Park Service in 1933.[11] A relatively new interpretive center at Corinth preserves the Battery Robinett, the site of much fighting during the Confederate attack in October 1862. It also interprets the Contrabands who sought freedom in the Union camps.
Confederate dead at Battery Robinett. (From Corinth unit)
All materials in this blog are copyrighted © 2020 by Jon Hunner.


[1] John Keegan, The American Civil War: A Military History (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 2009), 131.

[2] Exhibit text at Shiloh NMP Visitors’ Center, visited October 2016.

[3] Keegan, American Civil War, 132.

[4] Exhibit text at Shiloh NMP Visitors’ Center, visited October 2016.

[5] Kate Cumming, A Journal of Hospital Life in the Confederate Army of Tennessee. Quotes found in the exhibit at the Corinth Civil War Interpretive Center, visited October 2016.

[6] Ibid.

[7] Keegan, American Civil War, 133.

[8] Ibid., 160-61.

[9] Ibid., 133.

[10] Ibid., 134.


[11] Shiloh National Military Park -- https://www.nps.gov/shil.

Wednesday, April 29, 2020

Exit 32 – First Blood at Manassas National Battlefield and the Glorieta Battlefield Unit of the Pecos National Historical Park, Virginia and New Mexico


 The first salvo fired, the republic ruptured. Now how will each side put soldiers in the field, ready to fight? And not just fight, but win? At this exit, we consider two early battles in the Civil War that preview the bloody future — the First Battle of Manassas in Virginia and the Battle of Glorieta in New Mexico.
Armies at the beginnings of wars often fail to fight effectively. Generals struggle to adapt to new weapons and tactics, inexperienced soldiers are shocked with the carnage and mayhem, officers fight between themselves -- all these and more contributed to mistakes that cost men their lives and lost each side opportunities to seize a decisive victory and put an early end to the war.
Soon after Fort Sumter, politicians and newspapers cried out for quick action, and so the North and South clashed near a stream called Bull Run twenty-five miles from Washington D.C. to wrestle for control of a key railroad junction. Manassas marked the first real battle where North and South started to realize the brutal war ahead.[1]
NPS ranger giving a tour of the battlefield.
Two classmates from West Point’s class of 1838 faced each other at the head of the opposing armies at Manassas. General P. G. T. Beauregard from Louisiana had distinguished himself in the Mexican American War. In 1861, he commanded West Point, but resigned to led the action at Fort Sumter. He then took charge of Confederate forces in Virginia. He had to protect Richmond and threaten Washington. On the eve of the battle, Beauregard had 20,000 troops.
The commander of Union forces, General Irvin McDowell, also served in the Mexican American War and was an instructor at West Point. On July 1, 1861, the Union Army had 186,000 soldiers, of which McDowell devoted 34,000 to attack Beauregard. Both sides thought that an early victory would led to a quick end of the war. Both looked to Manassas for that victory.
https://www.nps.gov/carto/hfc/carto/media/MANAmap1.jpg
Map of the First Manassas battlefield (From https://www.nps.gov/carto/hfc/carto/media/MANAmap1.jpg)

McDowell began his twenty-five-mile march from D.C. toward Manassas on July 16, but due to ambling troops and supply delays, his army did not arrive until July 21. His men carried only three days of rations with not enough wagons available to deliver more. On July 21, some of McDowell’s troops engaged the Confederate center while others took a long roundabout march to try to skirt around their enemies’ left. Southern Signal Corps scouts on a hilltop saw the glinting of the sun off of weapons in the slow moving columns and warned Beauregard that his flank was in danger of getting turned.
Henry House from the Visitors' Center.
Then the two sides fell on each other with fury. At first, Union soldiers and cannonry pushed the Confederates back toward the railroad line. An eager battery led by Capt. James Ricketts advanced to the hill near the Henry House and blasted shrapnel into the advancing Confederates as rebel sharpshooters hiding behind the house picked off Union artillery men.

Above, statue of Gen. Jackson. Below, the stonewall quote on the base of his statue.
Enter General Thomas J. Jackson. Also a veteran of combat during the Mexican American War, Jackson led a large contingent of Virginians. At Manassas, the arrival of his troops in the afternoon rallied retreating Southerners. A nearby Confederate cried out: “There stands Jackson like a stone wall! Rally behind the Virginians!” giving the nickname to one of the best Southern generals. More Confederate troops arriving by train from the Shenandoah Valley flooded onto the battlefield and started pushing Union soldiers back. Perhaps the mad dash to the rear by horse-drawn Union wagons dispatched to get more ammunition for Ricketts’ cannons set off the panicked retreat among green troops.
The retreat turned into a rout as Northern soldiers (and sightseers) fled to D. C. Afterwards, Union forces then hunkered down around their capital. In the eleven-hour long battle at Manassas, the South lost 2,000 men killed, wounded, or missing. The North lost 3,000. The number of casualties shocked everyone. The fighting at First Manassas smacked away any notion that this would be a quick war. In fact, the Civil War “inaugurated a new kind of war, with giant armies wielding unstoppable machines, as if monsters with scales of steel had been let loose on the land to maul and maraud, and to eat even the innocent.”[2]
Arming their troops proved difficult for both sides. At the beginning of the war, the Union army had around 336,000 muskets and rifles while the Confederates had almost 274,000 arms, but only 20,000 were rifles.[3] The South seized arms in federal arsenals in their region but had few armories that produced guns. The North had more such factories, but the industry was in its infancy. So both sides turned to Europe for armaments.
Agents flush with cash flooded capitals of Europe scooping up guns at inflated prices. Buyers from North and South competed with each other, and even some individual northern states sent people to complicate the market even more. By summer of 1862, the Federal government had purchased nearly 727,000 guns of variable quality and age, often at double pre-war prices. By then, northern factories like Colt, Smith and Wesson, Sharps, and others had expanded their capacity and were producing adequate numbers of weapons while the South struggled to secure new armaments and gunpowder. As historian Allan Nevins comments: “Even when due weight is given the facts that the South fought mainly on the defensive, initially possessed better marksmen, and captured great quantities of Northern arms, this disparity [of guns] was an important element in deciding the outcome of the war.”[4]
The weapon of choice for the infantry was the Enfield or Springfield rifled muskets. The Enfield from England fired a .57 caliber bullet while the homegrown Springfield shot a .58 caliber one—close enough that when Springfields fouled after heavy use, soldiers used the smaller Enfield bullets to continue firing.
At first, many soldiers used a smooth bore musket, less accurate and not as deadly. Smoothbore muskets fired one ounce bullets at low velocity effective up to about 600 feet. The newly invented Enfield and Springfield rifles fired bullets with speeds of 960 feet per second and accurate to around 900 feet.  Not only did these new rifles have longer ranges, but their “minnié ball” bullets tore through a body at greater speeds than a musket ball, shattering bones and organs.
While soldiers do the fighting, their officers train them, organize their movements, and order them into harm’s way. Both sides struggled to find competent leaders. Over the first three years of the war, Lincoln appointed and eventually fired the following generals as either chiefs of the Army or commanders of the Army of the Potomac: Scott, McDowell, McClellan, Halleck, Burnside, Hooker, Meade, Halleck again, and Grant. Lincoln’s capacity for decisiveness in the face of incompetence helped the North win the war. 
On the other hand, many Confederate officers graduated from West Point or other military academies or had fought in the Mexican American War. Consequently, at least at first, Southern troops had better leadership. Nevins again:  “Not only were the Southern forces better coordinated, but they had better officers and showed superior morale.”[5]
Combat causalities of southern officers eventually reduced that advantage while the North began to find leaders who had grown into their roles. Douglas Southall Freeman’s three volume Lee’s Lieutenants details this loss to deaths and injuries of the South’s best generals.
Lack of proper training and leadership helps explain the Northern defeat at First Manassas. Union troops slowly advanced from Washington, D.C., but had provisions for only three days. Once they joined the battle, a flanking movement by General McDowell to try to turn the Confederate left developed slowly and was noticed by the Confederates. Finally, the quick shuttle of rebel soldiers from Shenandoah Valley by Jackson turned the tide. Some of the Southerners jumped off the trains and ran straight into battle.
An important lesson learned at this early point was the role of railroads in the Civil War. They provided rapid deployment of troops as well as supplied necessary materiel and food to keep men fighting. Railroads also brought the battered wounded back to hospitals. Railroad junctions proved vital for rapid responses to combat which was the main reason that McDowell and Lincoln targeted Manassas.
In addition to poor leadership by Northern officers, a more fundamental issue hampered their prosecution of the war. Discipline is key to an military unit, but as Nevins points out: “Americans were hostile to discipline and jealous of every encroachment on personal freedom…. It was the conversion of a loose, inchoate, uncrystallized society into one organized for a mighty and many-sided effort.”[6] An unintended consequence of the Civil War transformed the country from independently minded people to a more collective citizenry. The side that harnessed that organizational power best eventually won the war.
In the same month as the First Battle of Manassas, action out West also gave the South an early victory. On July 24, 1861, 250 Texans invaded southern New Mexico and captured the village of Mesilla in a brief exchange of musket and mountain howitzer fire. Texans then established a Confederate Territory in the bottom quarter of New Mexico (which at the time extended west to the Colorado River). That winter, General Sibley and 2,500 Confederates reinforced their territory’s capital at Mesilla with the ultimate goal of moving north and capturing the gold and silver mines in Colorado. If that went well, they wanted to pivot west onto the gold fields in California. That at least was the dream of General Sibley, who took command of the Confederates in Mesilla.
After consolidating control of southern New Mexico that fall, Sibley and his Confederates marched up the Camino Real to Santa Fe in February. Union troops retreated before advancing Texans, burning supplies along the way. Within a few weeks, a Confederate flag flew over the ancient Palace of the Governors on the plaza in Santa Fe.
Palace of the Governors on the plaza of Santa Fe.
After resting in the old Spanish colonial capital, Confederates then headed up the Santa Fe Trail towards Colorado. Twenty-five miles out, they ran into Union soldiers and cannons at Glorieta Pass. Union forces strategically retreated, waiting for reinforcements and falling back towards their own heavily defended Fort Union fifty miles to the rear.
On March 28, 1862, the two sides (each with about 1,300 soldiers) clashed on the Santa Fe Trail. By day’s end, Union forces had retreated another mile or so. As both sides bedded down, news came that electrified the New Mexicans and Coloradans and demoralized the Texans. The previous night, a column of Union soldiers led by Major John Chivington skirted around the Texans by climbing over a mountain and descended on the wagon train that held all their ammunition, supplies, and personal belongings. The Union forces torched the 100 wagons.
Although Texans were winning on the battlefield, they had to retreat down the Rio Grande valley since they now had little food and supplies. After driving the Confederates out of New Mexico, Union forces then targeted Navajos for removal from their ancestral lands to an inhospitable stretch of the Pecos River 300 miles to the east.
Why mention the Battle of Glorieta along with First Manassas? From Virginia westward, across verdant farmlands, through dense forests, over swollen rivers, great plains, and parched deserts, armies fought the Civil War in large and small battles. In total, over 300 named battles occurred in addition to thousands of skirmishes. This was a continental wide conflict with many side theaters. In fact, two weeks after Glorieta, the Battle of Shiloh on the Tennessee River began to pry open the South to water borne invaders from the North. We drive to Shiloh next. 
At the end of the first year of combat, the South had won more than the North. Lincoln replaced McDowell with General George McClellan and scrambled to find good news to satisfy both the public as well as his detractors in Congress. The Union began a crippling blockade of southern ports which eventually reduced the Confederacy’s export trade by two-thirds.[7] Both sides bivouacked for the winter of 1861-62, recruited and trained new soldiers, and looked for weaknesses in their enemy. Each side hoped for decisive victories in the coming year.

Manassas National Battlefield Park was established May 10, 1940.[8] The ruins of the Pecos Pueblo became a National Monument in 1965 to preserve the pre-contact Indian town and its Spanish colonial church. In 1993 with the addition of the Glorieta Battlefield , it became the Pecos National Historical Park.[9]
Signal Corp's flag. (From exhibit at Manassas NB)

All materials in this blog are copyrighted © 2020 by Jon Hunner.



[1] The Union named battles after nearby creeks, rivers, or other natural features. The Confederacy named battles after nearby towns. Since the NPS usually uses the nearby towns’ name, I use those as well.

[2] In the Civil War when we describe casualties, soldiers out of action comprise the whole number. So casualties include not just soldiers killed on the battlefield, but those wounded who could not return to combat and those missing—both killed who are not found as well as those who deserted; Jill Lepore, These Truths: A History of the United States (New York: W.W. Norton & Company, 2018), 293.

[3] Allan Nevins, War for the Union, 1861-1862: The Improvised War (New York: Koneky & Koneky, 1971), 344, 359.

[4] Ibid., 361.

[5] Ibid., 217

[6] Ibid.

[7] Keegan, The American Civil War: A Military History (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 2009), 139.

[8] Manassas National Battlefield Park -- https://www.nps.gov/mana.


[9] Pecos National Historical Park -- https://www.nps.gov/peco.