Thursday, April 9, 2020

Exit 12 – The First Shot of the Revolutionary War at Minute Men National Historical Park and Boston National Historical Park, Massachusetts


“Lay down your arms, ye damned rebels, lay down your arms!” With this terse warning from Major Pitcairn, his British Army guard of 150 Redcoats confronted the seventy-seven assembled Minute Men on the town green at Lexington, Massachusetts. On April 19, 1775, the militia had gathered to the alarms spread the night before by Paul Revere, William Dawes, and Dr. Samuel Prescott. Contrary to popular myth, at the time no one cried “The British are Coming!” Most colonials still considered themselves British. The cry that rang out through the New England countryside that night was “The Redcoats are Coming!”
The Green at Lexington where the fighting started.
At the Lexington Green, a shot rang out, and the militia scattered, some run down by the British Regulars who charged with bayonets, killing eight and wounding ten. The Regulars suffered no casualties. Pitcairn marshaled his jubilant troops back to command and rushed his men to Concord to capture a suspected stockpile of rebel arms and ammunition.
The fighting at Lexington and Concord in April 1775 sparked the American War for Independence which changed the world. The road to rebellion was a slow boil for the colonists in British America. Beginning in 1733 with the Molasses Act, taxes on essential colonial products raised the ire of the Americans. They grew more irate after the French and Indian War.
Burdened by paying for its growing world empire, Britain and its Parliament sought ways to make money from their American colonies. The First Lord of the Treasury, George Grenville, justified the taxes saying that they would go “toward defraying the necessary expenses of defending, protecting, and securing the said colonies and plantations.” But without representation in Parliament, some in the colonies declared that Parliament had no right to tax them.
Revolutions need many elements to succeed. They need a jointly perceived threat to motivate people to rebel. They need talented leaders to take charge and figure out how to effectively rebel. They require an effective network of communication to spread the word. And they need luck.
One particular network that proved effective involved the Masons. According to historian Niall Ferguson, George Washington first joined the Masons at the age of twenty and became master of the Alexandria Lodge in 1783. In 1789, he swore the oath of office as our first president on a bible from New York’s Masonic Lodge No. 1. Benjamin Franklin was grand master of his lodge in Philadelphia. Paul Revere networked through his Massachusetts Lodge whose membership grew by over 100 during the Revolutionary years.[1] Along with more informal networks like the Sons of Liberty and the Minute Men, spreading news and coordinating action helped fuel discontent with England and organize the rebellion.

A statue of a Minuteman at the Green at Lexington.
Talented writers fanned the flames of rebellion and justified the challenge to the British and King George III. Virginians Patrick Henry and John Dickinson, Pennsylvanian Benjamin Franklin, and Bostonian Samuel Adams stoked popular resentment with pamphlets, broadsheets, and articles decrying British tyranny and rallying the public with slogans such as “Give me Liberty or give me Death.” From leaflets to popular songs sung in taverns, the rebels organized against Britain.
Building on the growing resentment, rebels started boycotting British imports. Sassafras replaced British tea as the protestors’ drink of choice. Women made garments out of homespun cloth, merging fashion with defiance. Patriots organized armed militia to resist England. In Massachusetts, almost all men between sixteen and sixty served in their town’s militia, with the younger men joining a rapid response force, nicknamed the Minute Men. Many knew that once open rebellion erupted, they would face the best military in the world.
A particularly odious tax on the colonies was the Stamp Act of 1765. It required revenue stamps on newspapers and most printed material, even playing cards used in pubs. Thus, the Stamp Act angered the influential people who shaped public opinion—the newspaper editors, lawyers, and tavern owners. As a result, open acts of rebellion flared, including the sacking of the Bostonian homes of the Lt. Gov. Thomas Hutchinson and his brother-in-law Andrew Oliver, a Stamp Act commissioner. Even though Parliament repelled the Stamp Act in response to protests, in 1768, England sent troops to Boston to quell the growing rebellion.
What did the rebels want? They called for independence from an oppressive regime; for equality (but in truth, only for propertied white males); and for representation in government. Newly arrived from England, spitfire Thomas Paine published the influential Common Sense in January 1776. In it, he wrote:

It is not in the power of Britain to do this continent justice: … for if they cannot conquer us, they cannot govern us.… There are injuries which nature cannot forgive; she would cease to be nature if she did. As well can the lover forgive the ravisher of his mistress, as the continent forgive the murderers of Britain.[2]

Cries for rebellion like Payne’s unified the disparate colonies into a continent, into a whole land. Granted, the thin line of English settlements along the eastern seaboard ignored the vast reach of North America; nonetheless, colonials started seeing themselves as part of a new land, an entire continent, fighting against a corrupt Old World government. Consolidating this claim, they created a Continental Congress and a Continental Army to support their continental rebellion.
I arrived in downtown Boston on a hot August day. Among its tall skyscrapers and crush of people, I hoped to encounter the revolutionary spirit that had thrived here. I first stopped by Faneuil Hall and got in line with several hundred people. I asked the man in front of me if this was the right line for the Visitors’ Center. He shook his head: “No, I’m taking the oath.” On Thursdays, naturalization ceremonies occurred at the Great Hall of Faneuil Hall.  I shook his hand, congratulated him on becoming a citizen, and then entered by a different door into the air-conditioned  welcome center for the Boston National Historical Park.
A costumed guide giving a tour amid the sky-scrapers in downtown Boston.
There, I signed up for the Freedom Trail tour through downtown Boston led by NPS Ranger Bill. Standing across from Faneuil Hall, Bill told our group that this building had protected the rights of Englishman since 1742. These rights—to vote, to assemble, and to debate—had been threatened by new efforts of the Crown after the French and Indian War. Bill asked us to complete James Otis’s declaration spoken in Faneuil Hall, “Taxation without representation is…?” We parkgonauts shouted in unison: “Tyranny!” The colonists had no representatives in Parliament since the Lords did not want to share their power with the provincials.  Taxes sparked the rebellion, but political and civil rights fueled it.
We then went down an alley and crossed a busy street to stand in front of the Old State House. On March 5, 1770, a lone British sentry marched between his barrack and this building. He cried out as a group of youths pelted him with snowballs and rocks. Soldiers poured out of the nearby barrack and tussled with the gathering crowd. A British solder fired, then more shots rang out, killing five and wounding another eight. Ironically, one of the first persons killed in the fight for freedom was Crispus Attucks, a runaway slave who worked on ships in the harbor. The Boston Massacre escalated the conflict.
Old State House
Ranger Bill ended our walking tour in front of the Old South Meeting House, the largest building in British colonial America which could hold up to 5,000 people. At this Congregationalist Church, on December 16, 1773, Samuel Adams launched the Boston Tea Party. Spilling out of the church, a group of men disguised as Mohawk Indians stormed three ships in the Boston harbor and dumped 342 chests of tea into the frigid waters to protest taxes.
Old South Meeting House
Parliament punished Boston with the Coercive Acts (aka the Intolerable Acts) which closed the port until Boston paid over $1,000,000 in today’s dollars for the tea. The Crown declared martial law in Boston, and only Governor Thomas Gage could approve public assemblies. British military now ruled Massachusetts. Discontent grew in Boston and spread to other cities in the colonies.
Then in April 1775, fighting erupted north of Boston. After the British attacked the militia at Lexington Green, they continued to Concord. Nearby Minute Men swarmed to the sounds of gunfire as Redcoats searched for arms and ammunition. When the militia saw smoke coming from Concord, they feared that the British had torched the town. They charged the North Bridge occupied by Redcoats and exchanged fire which killed two Minute Men and eleven English soldiers. British Colonel Francis Smith ordered his men to retreat to Boston. They had not found a cache of weapons.
Ranger Rick with the Concord Bridge behind him.
At the Concord Bridge, I talked with NPS Ranger Rick, a veteran of the war in Afghanistan. In addition to his usual account of the action at the bridge, he talked about the use of bayonets in hand to hand combat. He talked from experience. After he returned from Southwest Asia, he used the GI Bill to get a degree in public history and then a job with the NPS. 
Biking back to Lexington on the path along the Battle Road, I came across a narrow bridge a mile east of Concord which created a bottleneck for the British marching back to Boston. Militia had shadowed the English and then ambushed them as they backed up for a quarter of a mile along the Battle Road. Some 1,000 militia flocking to the sounds of gunfire joined the fray. They forced the Redcoats to run a deadly gauntlet of musket fire. Near Lexington, the British column faced the men they had attacked that morning who exacted retribution from the Regulars. A British officer wrote about their retreat: “The Rebels kept the road always lined and a very hot fire on us without intermission; we at first kept our order and returned their fire… but when we arrived a mile from Lexington, our ammunition began to fail… so that we began to run rather than retreat in order.”[3] At Lexington, the Regulars ran into reinforcements sent from Boston, or their retreat would have been far worse.
The bottleneck on the Battle Road. Notice the marker on the right where British soldiers died.
Inconceivably, a ragtag group of colonial militia had forced the Redcoats to flee in disorder. The engagement shocked the British —almost three hundred men killed, wounded or missing, and the Crown’s forces now under siege in Boston. The Minute Men suffered ninety-three killed or wounded. As an irregular unit, the militia inflicted serious damage on the best army in the world by using tactics learned from Native Americans. The Americans succeeded by fighting an unconventional (at least by European standards) style of warfare.
After the first skirmishes near Boston that spring, conflicts erupted at Fort Ticonderoga and Crown Point in New York. Then, on June 17, militia from the Boston area resisted a Redcoat assault on the strategic heights above the town of Charlestown across from Boston. During the Battle of Bunker Hill (actually fought on Breed Hill), a first wave of 2,200 Regulars struggled uphill over fences and hastily constructed bulwarks. Volleys of bullets rained down from above and forced the Redcoats to retreat. They charged again, and again the militia fought back. The third British charge proved successful as Patriots started running out of ammunition. The British suffered 1,054 casualties including 232 dead while the Americans had 400 dead, wounded, or missing. British General Clinton complained: “A dear bought victory—another such would have ruined us.”[4]
Several consequences came out of these first armed clashes. First, with cold weather approaching and surrounded by a hostile force, the British abandoned Boston and retreated by boat to Halifax, Canada where they wintered. Second, British generals became more cautious in engaging home grown militia whose atypical combat proved effective. Third, King George III and Parliament decided to counter this rebellion with a show of force and sent a large contingent of soldiers for next summer’s campaign. Finally, the Continental Congress called for all able bodied men to join the rebel militia.
Not all Americans joined the rebellion. John Adams estimated that perhaps a third of the colonials wanted rebellion and freedom from England while another third remained loyal to King George. The rest stayed neutral, whether undecided or just not interested. In Adams’ accounting however, slaves did not register, and perhaps as many as one in five fled “American slavery in search of British liberty.”[5] This was as much a civil war as a unified struggle against the British. The Boston battles sparked the years of combat and destruction as armies marched across the colonies, killing one another and destroying whatever lay in their paths.
In May 1775, the Second Continental Congress convened in Philadelphia and in response to the fighting in Boston, declared the colonies independent and organized their defense. Congress elected George Washington to lead the nascent Continental Army which he did until the Battle of Yorktown in 1781. We now drive south to Philadelphia to pick up the Revolutionary story at the City of Brotherly Love.

President Eisenhower signed the Minute Man National Historical Park enabling act on September 21, 1959.[6] The Boston National Historical Park was created on October 1, 1974.[7] This park includes the Bunker Hill Monument, Dorchester Heights, Faneuil Hall, Old North Church, Old South Meeting House, and the Charleston Navy Yard where the tall ship USS Constitution is berthed.


The U.S.S. Independence undergoing restoration at Charleston shipyards across from Boston.



All materials in this blog are copyrighted © 2020 by Jon Hunner.


[1] Niall Ferguson, The Square and the Tower: Networks, Hierarchies and the Struggle for Global Power (New York: Penguin Books, 2017), 113-15.

[2] Erik Bruun & Jay Crosby, Our Nation’s Archives: The History of the United States in Documents (New York: Black Dog & Leventhal Publishers, 1999), 126-27.

[3] Joseph E. Stevens, America’s National Battlefield Parks: A Guide, (Norman: University of Oklahoma Press, 1990), 25.

[4] George Brown Tindall & David Shi, America: A Narrative History (New York: W.W. Norton & Company, 1996), 228.

[5] Jill Lepore, These Truths: A History of the United States (New York: W.W. Norton & Company, 2018), 94, 102.

[6] Minute Man National Historical Park-- www.nps.gov/mima.


[7] Boston National Historical Park-- www.nps.gov/bost.

No comments:

Post a Comment