Tuesday, April 28, 2020

Exit 31 – The First Salvo at Fort Sumter National Monument, South Carolina


 Viewed from the NPS ferry, Ft. Sumter looked unimposing; however, its low profile belied the importance it had in starting the Civil War. I admit I was a bit disappointed. I had trouble imaging the fort in April 1861. What helped was Paul, a volunteer guide on the ferry, who said that a different military installation -- Fort Point in San Francisco-- was a sister fort. I had visited the massive Fort Point earlier on my road trip, and I realized that I was looking at a stump of a fort, its fifty-five foot high walls bombarded first by Confederates and then in return, reduced to rubble by Union artillery.
Charleston has the best harbor along the southern Atlantic coast. Founded in 1670, it helped shape the South and the country. Closer to Africa than most other North American colonies, the port had the biggest slave market in the country.  A vibrant center of the South, in 1790 Charleston was the 4th largest city in the new nation.
Map of Charleston Harbor. (From exhibit at Ft. Sumter NM)
To protect Charleston’s harbor, the U.S. built Fort Sumter in 1829 by dumping New England granite onto a sand bar to create an island. Slaves made and laid the bricks for its massive walls. No ships entered Charleston without sailing under the guns of the fort. Then, in 1861, Charleston became the flashpoint for secession.
As the movement to abolish slavery in the North grew, a new national party emerged. The presidential election of 1860 saw a four-person race, including the Republican Party candidate Abraham Lincoln. The Republican platform did not call for the abolition of all slavery, but did for the prevention of its expansion into western territories. Lincoln won as the vote splintered among the four candidates, and Southern leaders rebelled against the threat to limit their rights to own slaves.
Secession winter (the time between Lincoln’s election and his inauguration) tore the country in two. From November on, Southerners argued about whether to stay in the Union. For many southern leaders, the threat to slavery and white supremacy was their primary concern. Jefferson Buford told the Alabama secession convention: “We are sent to protect, not so much property, as white supremacy.”[1] Confederate vice president Alexander Stephens praised their new constitution which secured white supremacy since “as a race, the African is inferior to the white man…. He is not our equal by nature and cannot be made so by human laws or human institution.”[2] Addressing South Carolina’s Democratic convention in 1860, J.S. Preston said: “Slavery is our King. Slavery is our Truth. Slavery is our Divine Right.”[3] South Carolina seceded first on December 12, 1861, followed by Mississippi, Florida, Alabama, Georgia, and Louisiana in January, Texas in February, Virginia, Arkansas, and North Carolina in April, and Tennessee in June.
Map of slaves in southern states. (From exhibit at Ft. Sumter NM)
After South Carolina seceded, eighty-five Union soldiers commanded by Major Robert Anderson bolted from nearby Fort Moultrie and rowed over to the stronger Fort Sumter. There they hunkered down in the fortification meant to be defended by 650. They waited for supplies and reinforcements.
Looking at Ft. Sumter from Ft. Moultrie. Ft. Sumter is just left of the sailboat in the distance.
Lincoln, newly installed as president, had a difficult choice about whether to send more troops or abandon the fort. More troops would provoke the South and possibly spark combat with the president looking like the aggressor. On the other hand, abandoning the fort would anger many of Lincoln’s supporters. So he sought a less confrontational path by sending non-military supplies to the fort and giving prior notice to the South that the ship was on its way.
Thus warned, Confederate President Jefferson Davis ordered Fort Sumter fired on before the relief ship arrived. On April 13, General P.G.T. Beauregard (one of Anderson’s professors at the West Point Military Academy) opened up with his batteries from Fort Moultrie.
Ft. Sumter under bombardment on April 13. (From exhibit at Ft. Sumter NM)

The thirty-four-hour bombardment lobbed 3,340 shells onto Fort Sumter. Anderson, low on men and supplies, surrendered with neither side suffering a casualty.[4] And so, the country that had drifted toward disunion for years erupted into a civil war. As Lincoln wrote: “The last ray of hope for preserving the Union peaceably expired at the assault on Fort Sumter.”[5]
The first salvo at Fort Sumter forced action. Lincoln called for mobilization of 75,000 men to serve for ninety days. Northern states quickly exceeded that call. Some Southern states that had not yet seceded moved into the Confederate camp, with the Virginia convention approving it on April 17. That spring, enthusiastic volunteers joined improvised military units in the South and the North, and each side struggled to train men not used to battlefield tactics and military discipline. Both sides also scrambled to find officers to lead the green recruits.
Inside Ft. Sumter today.
It takes time to figure out how to fight with large armies. New armies don’t win overnight. Training recruits, organizing their movement, supplying them with food, ammunition, and clothing takes coordination. A newly minted army, an army at dawn, learns by the mistakes it makes. Those mistakes cost men their lives, both in the early battles as well as in the missed opportunities that could have ended war and the resultant slaughter sooner. Few anticipated the wrath, carnage, and sorrow that was descending on the people of the crumbling republic.
As carnage began to engulf the nation, each side developed their strategies. Southern strategy involved defending their capital at Richmond and relying on the difficult geography of the region to help repel the invaders. If the South had stuck with that plan and not invaded the North, the war might have ended differently, perhaps with the Confederacy forcing the Union to concede through war weariness. But as the Richmond Examiner wrote in September 1861: “The idea of waiting for blows, instead of inflicting them, is altogether unsuited to the genius of our people.”[6]
For the North, Lincoln’s general-in-chief, Winfield Scott, devised the Anaconda Plan which sought to blockade Southern ports, control the waterways essential to movement and trade for the South, (in particular on the Mississippi, Ohio, Cumberland, and Tennessee Rivers), and hem in the insurrection with large armies on its borders. Scott wanted to strangle the rebellion like a boa constrictor without much combat. Other plans swirled around Lincoln, including vigorously attacking Virginia or driving the army through Tennessee and into the heart of Dixie.
After the first combat in summer of 1861, Lincoln’s plan evolved into something more complex as he wrote to General Halleck:

I state my general idea of this war to be that we have greater numbers and the enemy has greater facility of concentrating forces upon points of collision (because of his interior lines); that we must fail, unless we can find some way of making our advantage an over-match for his; and that this can only be done by menacing him with superior forces at different points, at the same time; so that we can safely attack, one, or both, if he makes no change; and if he weakens one to strengthen the other, forebear to attack the strengthened one but seize, and hold the weakened one, gaining so much.[7]

As Lincoln formed his cabinet and developed his war strategy in April, he did not know how many states would join the Confederacy. The border states of Virginia, Maryland, Delaware, Kentucky, and Arkansas waivered on supporting the Union, and even southern parts of Ohio and Indiana had pockets sympathetic to the insurrection. Dangerously, if Maryland joined the Confederacy, the federal capital would be surrounded by enemy forces.
A Confederate Maryland was not an abstract worry of Lincoln’s. On April 19, as soldiers from New York rushed to D.C. to defend it from an anticipated attack, a mob overwhelmed them as they transferred trains in Baltimore. Union infantrymen as well as some in the mob were killed or injured in the riot. Rebels in that city also destroyed railroad bridges to prevent troops from reaching D.C. Subsequent reinforcements from New England and Ohio had to find alternative routes around Baltimore for the next week. It seemed that Maryland would join the South until the state’s Unionists rallied in support. Then General Benjamin Butler occupied Baltimore in May and declared martial law to secure the state for the Union.
In the end, the eleven Confederate States of America (Alabama, Arkansas, Florida, Georgia, Louisiana, Mississippi, North Carolina, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, and Virginia)  spread over 900,000 square miles. The Union managed to hold the border states of Delaware, Kentucky, Maryland, Missouri, and later the splinter West Virginia.
Railroads played a major role in the war. The South had fewer railroad lines. In 1861, of the 31,000 miles of railroads in the country, only 9,000 ran through the South. The only Confederate line that ran east to west connected Richmond with Corinth, Mississippi, and a north-south route between Montgomery and Richmond was under construction. The North had several lines that ran through the border states which allowed rapid movement of troops and supplies into battlefields.[8]
In the Midwest, rivers proved decisive. Once the North controlled the Mississippi River, it split the Confederacy in two and opened up avenues of invasion. On the Ohio, Tennessee, and Cumberland Rivers, Union armies advanced to strike deep into the heart of the rebellion.
Map of Civil War actions. (From exhibit at West Point Museum)
The South had several advantages. Its landscape aided a defensive campaign with shorter interior lines. The South had many experienced military leaders as 313 commissioned officers—nearly a third of total in the U.S. Army—resigned and fought for the Confederacy. The South’s soldiers embraced a fighting spirit that thrived as an underdog, as determined men faced logistical hardships that the better provisioned Northerners did not.
The North’s strengths dwarfed those of the South. It had a developed industry capable of producing arms and materiel necessary to prosecute a continental war. Its greater population (20,000,000 vs. 8,000,000 plus 4,000,000 slaves) allowed it to suffer mounting casualties and still supply soldiers for the long term. Its railroads transported men and goods. Its navy blockaded southern ports. And its diplomacy insured that European countries, despite their dependence on Southern cotton, turned away from alliances that the Confederacy expected and sorely needed.
Each side had weaknesses that prolonged the war. Lincoln struggled to find generals strong-willed enough to prosecute this brutal war. Lincoln also wavered on why to fight—to preserve the Union? To end slavery? For racial equality? Lincoln and most Northerners wanted to primarily preserve the Union, to live under the Constitution which their grandparents had fought for, and to continue to unite the continent under one government. Not until he issued the Emancipation Proclamation in the fall of 1862 did Lincoln commit to the abolition of slavery.
With lesser industries and fewer people, the South faced a daunting task of matching the strengths of the North. Additionally, the Confederate’s national government was weakened by strong states’ rights which even interfered with the coordination of soldiers from different jurisdictions. Their constitution protected the sovereignty of states, similar to the Revolution’s Articles of Confederation. The South failed to win overseas allies and thought that the war would be short. In April, the Confederate Secretary of War predicted that “The flag which now flaunts the breeze here will float over the dome of the old Capitol at Washington before the first of May.”[9] Other voices in the South claimed that after a few Confederate victories, the North would negotiate for peace.
Both sides claimed God’s blessings. James Chestnut, a wealthy plantation owner and former South Carolina senator said that “commerce, culture, and Christianity derived their ‘chief earthly impulse’ from slavery.”[10] On the other hand, many Northerners knew their God did not countenance slavery. Both sides, as James McPherson writes, yelled battle cries to God.
Siege mortar mounted onboard Union gun boat. (From exhibit at Ft. Sumter NM)
The first state to secede, the place of the first salvos of the Civil War, and now a haven for Southern supplies, South Carolina and especially Charleston attracted the North’s ire. After its surrender of Fort Sumter, the Union zeroed in on it as a key target. For twenty-two months, Union cannons first from ships and then on land blasted the rebel stronghold. A Confederate log book from the fort recorded the action: “Aug. 18, 1863- enemy opened fire 5 a.m. to 7 p.m. 876 shots and shells fired. 452 struck outside, 24 inside, 180 passed over.” In total, Union cannons shot more than 44,000 shells in the almost two-year long bombardment which killed fifty-two Confederates and wounded 267.[11]
Ft. Sumter after Union bombardment. (From exhibit at Ft. Sumter NM)
Fort Sumter sparked the Civil War and in revenge, was reduced to rubble. As I stood at the rail of the receding ferry after my visit, I imagined a multi-storied brick fortress like Fort Point rising out of the straits at the mouth of Charleston Harbor. But I saw only a stump of a fort, a symbol of the amputated country much like the many Civil War veterans without arms and legs. I thought of how the legacy of the Civil War, of slavery and white supremacy, continues to haunt the United States like the pain from a phantom amputated limb.
Ft. Sumter from the ferry.
 Fort Sumter joined the NPS as a National Monument in 1948 under President Truman. Fort Moultrie was acquired on May 1, 1963 as a National Historic Site.[12]

All materials in this blog are copyrighted © 2020 by Jon Hunner.



[1] Dwight Pitcaithley, The U.S. Constitution and Secession: A Documentary Anthology of Slavery and White Supremacy (Lawrence, Kansas: University of Kansas Press, 2018), 24-25.

[2] Ibid., 25.

[3] Exhibit text at Fort Sumter Visitors’ Center at Liberty Square, visited September 2016.

[4] John Keegan, The American Civil War: A Military History (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 2009), 34.

[5] Exhibit text at Fort Sumter Visitors’ Center, visited September 2016.

[6] Keegan, American Civil War, 81.

[7] Ibid., 89-90.

[8] Ibid., 86-87.

[9] Allan Nevins, War for the Union, 1861-1862: The Improvised War (New York: Koneky & Koneky, 1971), 78.

[10] Ibid., 69.

[11] Exhibit text at Fort Sumter, visited 2016.


[12] Fort Sumter National Monument, www.nps.gov/fosu and http://www.nps.gov/fomo.

No comments:

Post a Comment