Monday, April 27, 2020

Exit 30 – The Causes of the Civil War at Harpers Ferry National Historical Park, West Virginia


             Something as horrific as a civil war impacts not just soldiers, but families, communities, even future generations. It consumes a nation. In the U.S., many events fueled the decision to secede, and motivations abound for why individuals fought once politicians made that decision. At this exit to Harpers Ferry NHP, we explore the causes of the Civil War and how the nation descended into the hell of countrymen killing each other.
"Jefferson's Rock" above Harpers Ferry with the Potomac River in the distance. 
Thomas Jefferson passed by Harpers Ferry with his daughter in 1783 on his way to serve in the Continental Congress in Philadelphia. He wrote in his Notes on the State of Virginia that it was “one of the most stupendous scenes in nature” and “worth a trip across the ocean” to witness. In the early republic, Harpers Ferry (with its abundant water power at the confluence of the Potomac and Shenandoah Rivers) was ripe for industrial development. As a result, President Washington chose it as one of the first federal armories where it served as a nexus for innovation in the early 19th century. Then in 1859, an event at Harpers Ferry added kindling to fire.
Map of Harpers Ferry. (From exhibit at Harpers Ferry NHP)
On Sunday October 16 that year, John Brown, two of his sons, and twenty other men including five African Americans set out from a nearby farm to attack Harpers Ferry. These abolitionists hoped to ignite a slave rebellion with arms liberated from the arsenal. They first captured the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad’s bridge that spanned the Potomac River and in the process, shot Heyward Shepherd. He died the next day. Shepherd, a free black luggage porter for the B & O, was their first victim.
Photo of Harpers Ferry and bridge over the Potomac River. (From exhibit at Harpers Ferry NHP)
Quickly, Brown’s raiders swept over the railroad bridge into town and kidnaped several plantation owners. Local men began to fire upon the raiders, and then militia from nearby Charlestown arrived. Seeking protection, the raiders holed up in the Armory, at the arsenal across the street, and at the Rifle Works down the road. Brown took refuge in the Armory’s Engine House, a thick brick building where he held his captives. A few of Brown’s men, particularly from the Rifle Works, tried to slip away, but most were gunned down. Brown’s son Watson was shot and killed as he escorted a hostage into the street to negotiate. The local men had no patience for raiders who wanted to free slaves.
Two future commanders of the Confederate Army responded to the raid. Lieutenant Jeb Stuart, a cavalryman with the Army, led ninety Marines into the conflict. Rushing by train from Washington D.C., they arrived around 11 p.m. on the 17th.  After calling for surrender which Brown ignored, future Confederate General Robert E. Lee ordered the Marines to storm the Engine House. In his report on the action, Lee wrote that in a few minutes, ten of Brown’s men died while the rest were captured. Five of the hostages also died, including the town’s mayor.
Reconstructed Engine House at Harpers Ferry where Brown took refuge.
Punishment came swiftly to Brown and his surviving raiders. One week after the raid, Brown faced trial in Charlestown. After a week of testimony, the jury took only forty-five minutes to convict him of treason and murder. On December 2, 1859, John Brown swung from a scaffold and became a potent symbol for both pro- and anti-slavery movements. The day before he died, he wrote: “I, John Brown, am now quite certain that the crimes of this guilty land will never be purged but with blood.” Henry David Thoreau had appealed for Brown’s life, writing “Is it not possible that an individual may be right and a government wrong?” He concluded that Brown’s commitment to equality made him “the most American of us all.”[1]
Brown’s raid on Harpers Ferry failed to spark a slave rebellion, but it did lead to an increase in abolitionists’ actions in the North. In the South, the raid raised fears of both slave revolts and northern attacks on slavery. Brown’s intention of forcing the issue of slavery onto center stage worked and edged the country toward a horrific civil war.
"Tragic Prelude" by John Steuart Curry at Kansas State Capitol. (From exhibit at Harpers Ferry NHP)
            Here’s two facts that illustrate the future horror: on a single day at the Battle of Antietam in September 1862, more than 23,000 men were killed or injured.  This one-day total was more than all of the causalities in all of the battles that the United States had fought up to that time and remains the single bloodiest day in the nation’s combat history.  During the four years of the Civil War, between 600,000 and 750,000 died with exact numbers hard to verify in the chaos of combat. Many more died from their injuries in the months and years afterwards. 
The legacy of the Civil War continues today as its battlefields attract millions of tourists, as its tactics are still studied, and as its causes and effects continue to stir heated debates. A conflict that engulfed a nation and lasted four years took decades to develop and had deep roots in American society. The tap root of the war was slavery.
The contradiction of a country established on liberty but dependent on slaves troubled some Founding Fathers and other citizens; however, the U.S. Constitution side-stepped the issue and did not mention “slavery” once. Instead they wrote “property” to denote slaves. The Constitution did include the “three-fifths clause” that representation in the House of Representatives “shall be determined by adding to the whole number of free Persons … three fifths of all other Persons.” So slaves amounted to little over half of a person for counting population which determined legislative representation.
In the early 19th century, the cauldron of disagreements about slavery began to boil over. Congress struggled to divide the Louisiana Purchase into free and slave states and territories. As the nation expanded westward, slavery took center stage. Would new territories allow slavery? In large part, the “battle of slavery was a battle over the West.”[2]
The Missouri Compromise of 1820 addressed this issue as it set the boundary between free and slave territories at the 36° 30’ parallel. Despite the compromise, Thomas Jefferson late in life worried about slavery: “This momentous question, like a fire bell in the night, awakened and filled me with terror…. I considered it at once as the knell of the Union. It is hushed … for the moment, but this is a reprieve only, not a final sentence.” As the century progressed, the reprieve and compromises slowly unraveled, strained by sectional conflicts and by competing economic, moral, and Biblical arguments about slavery.
Map of Missouri Compromise (From exhibit at Ft. Sumter NM)
The fire bell rang more ominously in the 1850s. First, the Compromise of 1850 sought to settle whether slavery would exist in new territories gained from the Mexican American War. This Compromise admitted California as a free state and allowed the territories of New Mexico and Utah to decide for themselves. As recompense to Southerners, the Fugitive Slave Act forced Northerners to assist in the capture of escaped slaves.
Above, map of Compromise of 1850. Below, map of Kansas-Nebraska Act. (Both from exhibit at Ft. Sumter NM)
The Kansas-Nebraska Act of 1854 allowed Kansas to enter as a potential slave state, even though it was above the Missouri Compromise’s demarcation line. A Supreme Court case involving rights of slaves added more fuel to the fire. Dred Scott, a slave whose owner had taken him and his wife to live in the free states of Illinois and Minnesota and the territory of Wisconsin for several years argued that this entitled him to emancipation. In the 1857 Dred Scott v. Sanford case, the Court found that no black, slave or free, could claim citizenship and thus, Scott could not petition the court for his freedom. Additionally, Supreme Court Chief Justice Roger B. Taney ruled that slavery could not be banned in the nation’s territories. The Dred Scott case stoked the fire of northern abolition while doing little to settle southern discontent. Commenting on the decision, Douglass wrote: “Slavery lives in this country not because of any paper Constitution, but in the moral blindness of the American people.”[3]
Statue of Dred and Harriet Scott in front of the Old Courthouse in St. Louis where their law suit was first heard.
Slave labor was essential for the economy of the South. By 1860, the region produced 1,650,000,000 pounds of cotton.[4]  Much of that cotton supplied the textile mills of old and New England. During the first half of the 19th century, cotton far outpaced all other American foreign exports. The twelve richest counties in the country resided in the South, and in the 1840s and 1850s, the region constituted the fourth largest economy in the world. Slaves produced much of this wealth.
            Even today, many people argue about the causes of the Civil War. Some say it concerned state’s rights or involved unfair tariffs. Others that it came from protecting regional ways of life. When I toured the Petersburg Battlefield, a man walked up at the end of the tour and said that everyone knows that the Civil War was about money. I politely differed with him. I agreed that the North fought to protect its growing industrial might and so profits were a motivation. But for the South, protecting slavery was the primary cause which politicians voted in approving secession.
As proof, take the Vice-President of the Confederate State of America, Alexander Stevens, own words: “[Our] foundations are laid, its cornerstone rests, upon the great truth that the negro is not equal to the white man; that slavery, subordination to the superior race is his natural and normal condition.”[5] Virginian George Fitzhugh graphically wrote: “Men are not born physically, morally, or intellectually equal. It would be far nearer the truth to say, ‘that some are born with saddles on their backs, and others booted and spurred to ride them,’ – and the riding does them good.”[6] In January 1861, the Mississippi “Declaration of Causes of Secession” declared that “Our position is thoroughly identified with the institution of slavery—the greatest material interest in the world.”[7] John Goode, Jr., a delegate to the Virginia Secession Convention claimed: “And when we of the South have begged of the people of the North for peace… they have replied… that there can be no peace so long as we claim the right to hold property in slaves. There, sir, is the foundation of the whole difficulty.”[8] Numerous leaders in the South agreed with Stevens that preserving slavery was the reason to leave the Union.
Slave holders in the southern states. (From exhibit at Harpers Ferry NHP)

The South did not need to leave the Union to protect slavery. As Lepore notes: “Southern slave owners, a tiny minority of Americans, amounting to about 1 percent of the population… desperately needed and relied on the power of the federal government to defend and extend the institution of slavery.”[9]  In fact, by seceding Southerners lost the power to stop attempts by Congress to abolish it. To pass an amendment to the Constitution to abolish slavery, three quarters of the thirty-three states in 1860 had to approve it. With thirteen Southern states against such an amendment, the required twenty-four needed for passage would fall short. Once out of the Union, southern states lost their ability to thwart an abolition amendment, which passed in 1865 as the Thirteenth Amendment. Southerners were consumed with the fake news that the North could abolish slavery and bolted the Union to escape this hallucination.
            So why do people claim causes for the conflict other than slavery? Not surprisingly, descendants of Confederate veterans see their ancestors as fighting for more nobler reasons —like ensuring states’ rights or resisting northern aggression, not for enslaving fellow human beings. The Lost Cause myth grew after the Civil War to help shift the reason away from slavery to something more acceptable; however, transcripts from debates of the U.S. Congress and from the secession conventions in the South between November 1860 and May 1861 reveal that states seceded to protect slavery.[10]
            Granted, this is tricky territory, partially because the Civil War is still contentious in our nation’s history. But to dive into the Civil War as we will over the next eight chapters, I want to be clear about what caused the war. To be sure, not everyone fought for (or against slavery), and true, many whites in the North agreed with Southerners that blacks were inferior. Despite whatever the individual soldiers’ motivations for putting their lives on the line, the South’s political leaders said at the time that they fought to protect slavery and white supremacy.
After Brown’s raid, Harpers Ferry continued to see action. In April 1861, Virginian troops, led by General Thomas (Stonewall) Jackson, captured the town and sent its weapons-making machinery south to produce arms for the Confederacy. In the fall of 1862, Jackson and his troops returned, laid siege to the town, and forced the surrender of the federal troops there, the largest such Union surrender during the Civil War.
Storer College students (From exhibit at Harpers Ferry NHP)
Once the war ended, people at Harpers Ferry continued to fight for civil rights. Free Will Baptists created Storer College to teach freed-slaves, which became a center for civil rights struggles in the later part of the 19th and into the 20th century. At the second meeting of the Niagara Movement at Storer College, W.E.B. DuBois called for these reforms: the vote for African American men; an end to discrimination in public accommodations; that the 14th and 15th amendments be honored; that laws be enforced “against the rich as well as the poor… against white as well as black;” and that “we want our children educated.”[11] This meeting helped create the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP) in 1909.
Members of the Niagara Movement. Notice WEB DuBois fourth from right in front row. (From exhibit at Harpers Ferry)
Harpers Ferry has played a significant role in our nation’s past.  As a transportation center, an early site of the industrial revolution, a flash point for the Civil War, and a center for civil rights, this place has instigated and witnessed major events that altered our highway of history.

President Franklin Roosevelt signed legislation creating Harpers Ferry National Monument on June 29, 1944. It became a National Historical Park in 1963.[12]
John Brown at different ages in his life (From exhibit at Harpers Ferry NHP)

All materials in this blog are copyrighted © 2020 by Jon Hunner.


[1] Jill Lepore, These Truths: A History of the United States (New York: W.W. Norton & Company, 2018), 285, 284.

[2] Ibid., 267.

[3] Ibid., 270.

[4] http://mshistorynow.mdah.state.ms.us/articles/161/cotton-in-a-global-economy-mississippi-1800-1860

[5] http://www.legendsofamerica.com/ah-slaverycivilwar.html

[6] Lepore, These Truths, 256.

[7] “Slavery as a Cause of the Civil War,” a NPS brochure from the Appomattox Court House NHP.

[8] Ibid.

[9] Lepore, These Truths, 223.

[10] Dwight Pitcaithley, former chief historian of the NPS, plowed through thousands of pages of what Southerners said at the time to uncover why they seceded. See his The U.S. Constitution and Secession: A Documentary Anthology of Slavery and White Supremacy (Lawrence, Kansas: University of Kansas Press, 2018).

[11] Exhibit text at African American Museum at Harpers Ferry, visited September 2016.


[12] Harpers Ferry National Historical Park  -- https://www.nps.gov/hafe/index.htm.

No comments:

Post a Comment