Sunday, April 12, 2020

Exit 15 – The Turning Point at Saratoga National Historical Park, New York



In the rolling hills overlooking the Hudson River in upstate New York, a battle turned the Revolutionary War. Thirty miles north of Albany, in combat which began in late September 1777 and bled into middle October, the American army defeated a major British force. In doing so, they thwarted Britain’s counterinsurgency plan to split the rebellion in two and isolate the fractious New Englanders from the other colonies. The victory convinced the French to side with the Americans against their ancient foe. Heroes and villains arose on this battlefield and gave rise to one of best known traitors in our history. The fate of the revolution swirled around the Battle of Saratoga.
            The British strategy in 1777, while classic in its attempt to divide and conquer the colonies, proved difficult to implement. From Canada, General Burgoyne led 9,000 soldiers (a combined force of Redcoats, American Loyalists, German mercenaries, and Native American allies) into New York hoping to rendezvous with two other British columns around Albany.
At the previous exit, we saw how a  British force led by Lt. Colonel Barry St. Leger invaded from Lake Ontario but ultimately stalled at Fort Stanwix and retreated back to Canada. The third vector, led by General William Howe, was supposed to move north from New York City to join with the other two forces and cut the colonies in half. As envisioned by the British commander General Howe in the fall of 1776, this plan held promise.
Then Howe had a change of heart. Perhaps the British defeat at Trenton at the turn of the new year changed his mind about the 1777 campaign.  Howe, confident that the Canadian invasion would succeed, decided to capture the Patriot capital at Philadelphia instead. From New York in June, Howe loaded his 19,000 troops on ships to avoid tramping to Philadelphia through a hostile countryside. Storms delayed their arrival so that Howe’s army finally entered Philadelphia on September 25. Washington and his troops abandoned the City of Brotherly Love and retreated to Valley Forge for the winter. We drive to Valley Forge in the next chapter.

General Gates by Charles Willson Peale 1782
General Bourgoyne by Sir Joshua Reynolds 1767

Despite Howe’s change of plans, the British strategy to split the colonies remained. The American forces along the Hudson River —first under General Philip Schuyler and then with Horatio Gates who replaced him in September 1777—had to prevent Burgoyne’s southward advance. General Gates had his Patriots fortify Bemis Heights some two miles north of the village of Stillwater, overlooking the Hudson River and the road along its west bank. Their fortified positions, supported by twenty-two cannons, commanded the views of the river and the road as the British soldiers funneled into this natural bottleneck. Realizing that neither Howe nor St. Leger were coming but that winter approached, Burgoyne decided to fight his way through the Americans to reach safe haven in Albany.
American cannons protecting Bemis Heights and the road to Albany.

The two armies clashed at Saratoga over several weeks with two main battles, the first on September 19 and the second on October 7. NPS Ranger Roger at the Saratoga Visitors’ Center walked me over to a 3-D map of the battlefield and using a laser pointer, talked me through the action. At noon on the 19th, English scouts encountered Colonel Daniel Morgan’s light infantry at Freeman Farm, and the first combat at Saratoga began. Each side advanced and retreated over the afternoon as fierce fighting raged. With 13,000 troops, the Patriots under the command of General Gates pressed hard against the 4,000 British, 3,200 German, and 1,800 Canadian, Loyalist, and Native American soldiers. While neither side won a decisive victory, the British held the field and waited for Howe’s reinforcements from New York. They waited in vain.
Map of battlefield on Sept. 19. (From exhibit at Saratoga NHP Visitors' Center)
Colonel Tadeusz Kosciuszko, a Polish military engineer and volunteer to the Patriot cause, oversaw the building of the American bulwarks and redoubts. From the artillery fortifications at Bemis Heights above the Hudson River to the Neilson Farm about a mile to the west, the Continentals presented a fortified front against British attack. After the first battle, the British threw up their own timber and earthen breastworks near the Freeman Farm. This secured their western flank and protected the British line east to Burgoyne’s headquarters on a cliff above the Hudson River.
Monument to Col. Kosciusko who engineered the fortifications seen in the background.
Gate’s official report of the September 19 battle did not acknowledge Arnold’s efforts on the rebels’ left flank. According to biographer Nathaniel Philbrick: “Arnold became convinced that Gates…had robbed him not only of the credit he deserved (and needed if he were ever to win his proper seniority as a major general), but also of the most prized corps under his command. Arnold was predictably fuming, and that night he confronted Gates in his quarters.”[1] Disagreeing to agree, Gates heatedly gave Arnold permission to leave camp and take his complaints in person south to General Washington. Now without a command, Arnold still hung around the American camp at Neilson Farm.
With supplies running low, Burgoyne decided to break the stalemate on October 7. He sent soldiers to probe the American left flank for any weaknesses in advance of a major attack. At Barber’s Wheatfield near Freeman’s Farm, the Continental Army attacked and rolled back the Redcoats. Within minutes, 4,000 men came together in furious fighting.
Barber's Wheatfield
When Arnold heard the sound of battle, he rushed out of his tent at Neilson’s Farm and galloped toward battle. He rallied the Patriots to assault the center of the British line. Despite having his horse shot out from under him, Arnold continued to lead attacks on the Balcarres Redoubt and then the Breymann Redoubt. One veteran of the battle recalled about Arnold: “He didn’t care for nothing; he’d ride right in. It was ‘Come on, boys!’ ‘twasn’t ‘Go boys!’ … there wasn’t any waste timber in him.” Washington concurred: Arnold “always distinguished himself as a judicious, brave officer of great activity, enterprise and perseverance.”[2] Despite turning the British right flank by capturing their redoubts and forcing them to retreat, Arnold was arrested by Gates since he had no official command. Perhaps this led to him turning traitor.
Before I bicycled around the Saratoga Battlefield to get a feel for the landscape, I inquired about the monument to Benedict Arnold. The volunteers at the front desk nodded knowingly and said that many visitors asked it at Saratoga. As I pedaled the park’s tour road, the smells from the dense woods alternated between sweet and musty. This is hilly country. Climbing up from the fortifications at Bemis Heights overlooking the river, I rode across the open fields bordered by forests and came upon the redoubts that secured Burgoyne’s right flank. Here Arnold rallied the rebels, sealed the victory, but lost his horse and his patriotic way.
A granite monument near this decisive point in the Battle of Saratoga celebrates Arnold’s leg with a carved image of a boot. On the other side of the shrine, engraved in stone are these words: “In memory of the ‘most brilliant soldier’ of the Continental Army who was desperately wounded on this spot the sally port of BORGOYNES GREAT WESTERN REDOUBT 7th October, 1777 winning for his countrymen the decisive battle of the American Revolution...” A tribute to the patriotic leg (which he lost in the war) fails to name the man himself.
Monument to the patriotic leg of a traitor.
Perhaps embittered by his treatment at Saratoga, perhaps because his wife was from a Loyalist family, Arnold started to provide military intelligence to the British. When his plan to hand over the strategic West Point on the Hudson River to the British in 1779 failed due to the capture of his British liaison Colonel John André, Arnold switched to British command. Upon learning of Arnold’s treachery, Patriot General Nathaniel Greene lamented: “How black, how despised. Loved by none, hated by all—once his country’s idol, now her horror.”[3] One of the Patriots’ best generals had turned against the Revolution. Arnold then fought for the English as a Brigadier General and died in London in 1801.
As the British retreated on October 7 with their right flank shredded, one of Burgoyne's most valued commanders, General Simon Fraser, fell mortally wounded. Burgoyne withdrew his troops. He and his army retreated north a bit, halted, then surrounded by the rebel army and short on supplies, he surrendered on October 17. This crucial American victory renewed the Patriots' hopes for independence, secured vital foreign recognition and support, and forever changed the face of the world.
Map of British retreat from British stronghold overlooking the Hudson River.
The victory at Saratoga was the first time that a major British army had suffered a defeat. Before Saratoga, France had actively but secretly funneled funds and military supplies to the “Insurgents” as they called them. Young Frenchmen like La Fayette had fought on the side of the Americans, but after Saratoga, France threw its support to the colonists in their war against the English, partially to revenge the defeat from the French and Indian War and partially to support the call for liberty emerging from the colonies.
When Saratoga showed that the British could be defeated, “a formal alliance with the new United States was set up: the Treaty of Alliance as well as the Treaty of Amity and Commerce were signed in Paris on February 6, 1778 by Americans Benjamin Franklin, Silas Deane, Arthur Lee, and Conrad Alexandre Gérard… who represented the king.”[4] That June, France and Britain declared war against each other.
The French sent valuable military supplies and ships to America which allowed the revolution to continue for four more years. They also committed soldiers and warships to the cause which proved decisive at the Battle of Yorktown in 1781. After Saratoga, danger still stalked the Patriot forces and the revolution, but with French arms, troops, and warships, the balance began to swing toward the Americans.
At Saratoga in the autumn of 1777, American forces met, defeated in combat, and forced a major British army to surrender. The victory proved decisive in capturing not just support from the French, but from Spain and the Netherlands. Granted, the British still held New York City and other parts of the colonies, its warships and soldiers still attacked  often with impunity, and the war was far from over. Nonetheless, the Battle at Saratoga was the turning point in the American Revolution.

New York began managing Saratoga Battlefield as a state park in 1927. It became a National Historical Park on June 1, 1938.[5] In addition to Saratoga Battlefield, three other units compose this NHP—the reconstructed Schuyler House, the Saratoga Monument, and Victory Woods.
A brewer at a living history Day at Shuyler's Farm, near where the British surrendered in Oct. 17.

All materials in this blog are copyrighted © 2020 by Jon Hunner.




[1] Nathaniel Philbrick, Valiant Ambition: George Washington, Benedict Arnold and the Fate of the American Revolution, (New York: Viking 2016), 154.

[2] Joseph E. Stevens, America’s National Battlefield Parks: A Guide (Norman: University of Oklahoma Press, 1990), 33.

[3] Stevens, America’s National Battlefield Park, 34.

[4] Exhibit text at Bibliothèque Municipales de Versailles, visited in July 2017.


[5] Saratoga National Historical Park—www.nps.gov/sara.

No comments:

Post a Comment