Wednesday, April 1, 2020

Exit 5 – A Fork in the Road: Contact and the Columbian Exchange


Between each section, Driven by History will consider the various possibilities facing Americans at that junction of time and will examine the consequences from taking a particular fork in the road. We often assume there is historical inevitability, that the past happened the way it did because it was certain. Not so. People make decisions and events impact actions so that the history highway is a crooked roadmap. Powerful forces, sometimes people and sometimes natural events, shift human history onto totally new paths with unintended consequences. Throughout our travels, we will look at these forks in the road at key moments in the nation’s past as we transition from one section to the next. At Exit 5, we explore the fork in the road that came from the initial contacts between Native Americans and Europeans.

Contact
Trade has fueled human experience since the beginning of time. It is one of our distinguishing characteristics.  Exchanging what you have with what you need or want is one of our oldest professions. We seek out new cultures for resources both tangible as well as intangible. We explore to satisfy the need to make our lives different and hopefully better. Trade revolutionizes peoples and cultures and thus transforms our world.
During the 14th and 15th centuries, pestilence, war, famine, and death ruled Europe with the Black Plague, the Hundred Years War, and the Islamic occupation of Spain and parts of Eastern Europe. In the midst of this turmoil, Portugal saw an opportunity to take the lucrative Asian trade away from Venice and Genoa, so Prince Henry the Navigator sponsored systematic explorations of Africa’s Atlantic coast.
Portuguese ships sailed down the west coast of Africa using maps, compasses, and Arab tools like the astrolabe and quadrant to aid in safe navigating. The caravel, a new type of ship, assisted with the dangerous voyages. Its triangular lateen sails allowed for windward sailing.
When Constantinople fell to Ottoman Sultan Mehmed II in 1453, the overland Silk Road which brought spices, silks, and other goods from Asia to Europe was severed. Explorers and merchants needed to find new routes to Asia.
While Portuguese sailors went south, Spanish ones sailed west for the illusive route to Asia. In Spain at the end of the 15th century, King Ferdinand and Queen Isabella ratified the Treaty of Granada with Boabdil, sultan of Granada, ending the over 700 years of Muslim occupation of Spain. Freed from Muslim domination, Spain looked to expand and so on August 3, 1492, Christopher Columbus cast off from southwestern Spain to cross the gray Atlantic Ocean. His three ships – one carrack, the Santa María, and two smaller caravels, the Pinta (the Painted), and the Santa Clara, nicknamed the Niña – on October 12, 1492 landed on the Bahaman Islands.
They encountered the Arawak, who the Europeans mistook for people from India, and called them “Indians.” During encounters with a new world, people fit the unfamiliar into preconceived concepts such as naming Native Americans “Indians.” This fork in the road, choosing to name native peoples for someone who they weren’t, set the stage for misunderstandings that continue to impact these colliding cultures. It was not a small mistake. At contact, an estimated 75,000,000 lived in the Americas—more than Europe’s population at the end of the 15th century.[1]
Columbus’s contact initiated an unprecedented period of interactions and exchanges unknown to the world before or since. New peoples, new lands, new plants and animals, new beliefs, and new sources of wealth and bounty poured from the Americas into Europe and from Europe to the Americas. This American windfall enriched Europe and set the stage for modern nation states. Just in the 16th century, Europeans shipped nearly 200 tons of gold and 16,000 tons of silver back to their home countries, fueling new types of businesses and trade, fueling a rise in capitalism.[2]
America did not get its name from Columbus (who never realized that he had not reached Asia), but from Amerigo Vespucci, an Italian sailor who sailed to the “New World” several times between 1502 and 1504. Accounts describing these expeditions, attributed to Vespucci, argued these were not islands off the coast of Asia, but in fact an entirely new continent. In 1507, mapmaker Martin Waldseemüller published a new world map showing this new continent and named it after Amerigo, mistakenly believing that the Italian had discovered it.[3]
Almost two decades after Columbus’s first contact, Hernán Cortés de Monroy y Pizarro led a Spanish expedition from Cuba to secure the interior of New Spain (Mexico) and established a colony there. Landing at Vera Cruz on the Gulf of Mexico in February 1519 with eleven ships, 500 men, thirteen horses, and several cannons, he scuttled his ships to prevent any possibility of retreat. His army then marched on Tenochtitlan, the capital of the Aztec empire and home to over 200,000 people. After several years of fighting, assassinations, and sieges of Tenochtitlan, the Aztec finally fell to Cortés’ soldiers and Indian allies in August 1521. The gold of the Aztecs fueled the fever of the conquistadors who subsequently found a new source of the precious metal in the empire of the Incas in Peru.
As Spaniards explored and colonized the Caribbean and Central and South America in the 16th century, they also attempted several settlements in North American. A colony in Georgia in 1526 lasted only three months. Ones at St. Petersburg, Florida in 1527, North Carolina in 1566, and Virginia in 1570 all struggled. With discoveries of gold and treasures of the Aztecs and the Incas, the Spanish believed that more golden cities waited for them north of New Spain.
Europeans also explored the Atlantic seaboard. In 1524, Giovanni da Verrazano sailed a French expedition north from South Carolina, making landfalls all the way up to Newfoundland. That same year, Estevão Gomes, a Portuguese cartographer, explored from Nova Scotia to Florida.
In the early 16th century, fishermen from England, France, Spain, and Portugal discovered abundant fishing grounds off of Cape Cod, named for the very fish they sought. Some of these ships landed and traded with coastal Indians. This trade began the Columbian Exchange which invented the North America that we know today.

 The Columbian Exchange
As we have seen in previous chapters, sophisticated civilizations inhabited the Western Hemisphere. Europeans crashed in, trading, sometimes plundering, and disrupting Native American lives. Gold, silver, food, and other valuables sailed east to Europe while metal tools, horses, diseases, and a crusading religion came west.
The Columbian Exchange rapidly transformed cultures. For example, Europeans knew how to manufacture and use hard metal, especially iron. Iron allowed for more durable tools—from metal pots and pans to nails to weapons. Preparing fields with metal tools improved farming, and hunting with guns enhanced meat harvesting. With metal pots and pans, cooking grew easier. Defending or attacking foes with metal tipped spears, with iron swords, and with guns proved more effective than stone weapons. Contact brought benefits along with disruption.
Europeans with their long experience of livestock husbandry brought new animals with them. Horses, cattle, sheep, hogs, fowl, and other animals provided for work and food. Plowing a field with oxen, hauling goods and people on horse drawn wagons, feeding multitudes through the cultivation of livestock, such differences in protein and in mobility transferred to Native Americans. Until the Columbian Exchange, Native Americans traveled by foot along trade networks and migration routes. European animals revolutionized their transportation capabilities.
For their part, Native Americans knew how to grow multiple crops across the continent.  From the hot deserts in the Southwest to the cold woodlands of the north, native peoples throughout the Americas produced abundant harvests of nutritious food.  They created astounding innovations in horticulture. Corn from Central America and potatoes from Peru, combined with sugar cane, chocolate, chiles, tomatoes, tobacco, squashes, beans, and manioc transformed nutrition for the people of Europe and then Africa and Asia. In fact, many of these foods provided Americans a better diet than the Europeans had at the time. These new foods help explain the worldwide population explosion since Contact.
Europeans reciprocated by bringing new crops to the Americas. Wheat and rice adapted well to the prairies and lowlands of the continent. Fruit trees like apples and peaches flourished along the Eastern Seaboard. In addition to the assortment of plants and animals which the Europeans introduced, they also introduced deadly germs.
Smallpox, tuberculosis, cholera, measles, diphtheria, trachoma, whopping cough, chicken pox, bubonic plague, malaria, typhoid fever, amoebic dysentery, influenza, and other deadly illnesses swept through Indian communities since they had not acquired immunity to these diseases. First contact between explorers and Native Americans quickly spread diseases to other tribes, sometimes even before they had seen a European. Death swept through native communities, and some European explorers and traders found abandoned villages without connecting their own roles in spreading fatal diseases.
Here is an eyewitness account from Roanoke colony. The nearby tribe “began to die quickly. The disease was so strange that they neither knew what it was, nor how to cure it.”[4] The same happened farther north when Pilgrims arrived in Massachusetts in 1620. They observed that thousands had “died in a great plague not long since; and pity it was and is to see so many goodly fields, and so well seated, without man to dress and manure the same.”[5] Colonists took over these abandoned fields in Massachusetts and elsewhere, often seeing divine providence in preparing the land for them. Over the centuries, disease killed more Native Americans than warfare or displacement. An estimated 90% of the Native Americans in the Western Hemisphere at contact succumbed over the resulting centuries, often to deadly European germs.
In addition to technologies and food, the Columbian Exchange affected religious beliefs. For many Native Americans, living spirits animated their natural world. For example, private land ownership did not exist for many of the tribes, since Mother Earth was a deity. How could mere humans own a part of a god?
Europeans held an opposing view about land. Humans could own it and do what they wanted with land and its bounty. When the Dutch bought Manhattan Island from Lenape Indians for sixty guilders in 1626, the Indians had a contrary concept of land ownership. Selling Manhattan for the Lenape was similar to finding a rube to buy the Brooklyn Bridge today.
Europeans believed in monotheism. In Spain with their recent wars against Muslims, these colonizers wanted to conquer not just land and communities but peoples’ beliefs. Having a god which required evangelism brought a radicalization to the Columbian Exchange.
When different peoples meet, a cultural exchange occurs. In linguistics, when someone switches from their dominant language to another one, experts call this “code-switching.” A cultural code-switching happens when people co-mingle, adopting and adapting another culture’s fashion, food, languages, lifestyles, music, and beliefs for their own. Humans have borrowed from other cultures since time immemorial, so this is not unique to the Columbian Exchange. So, with the encounter between Native Americans and Europeans, both peoples exchanged key elements of their cultures to create a new way of living and a new world of humans.

Columbus began the encounter with Americans which profoundly changed world history. Interactions between Europeans and Native Americans brought together different worldviews, different religious beliefs, different lifeways, and different technologies. This altered the way people lived, worked, ate, worshiped, and played. The mix of peoples and cultures throughout the Western Hemisphere created a vibrant weaving of innovations and experiences that continues to impact our lives today.

In Tour 1 on Pre-contact Native Americans, we examined a few of the 500 nations of North America. We now begin to explore the European colonizers by driving along El Camino Real de Tierra Adentro, by returning to Jamestown, by taking an exit to Plimouth Plantation, and by visiting Grand Portage. We will go to places where history first happened between Americans and Europeans.


All materials in this blog are copyrighted © 2020 by Jon Hunner.


[1] Jill Lepore, These Truths: A History of the United States (New York: W.W. Norton & Company, 2018), 9.
[2] Lepore, These Truths, 17.
[3] Yuval Noah Harari, Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind,(London: Vintage, 2015), 320.
[4] David B. Quinn, ed. The Roanoke Voyages, 1584–1590: Documents to Illustrate the English Voyages to North America (London: Hakluyt Society, 1955), 378.
[5] Edward Winslow, Nathaniel Morton, William Bradford, and Thomas Prince, New England’s Memorial (Cambridge: Allan and Farnham, 1855), 362.

No comments:

Post a Comment