Wednesday, May 6, 2020

Exit 39 – A Fork in the Road: Reconstructing the Union at the Andrew Johnson National Historic Site


 In his second inauguration address, Lincoln called on the country “to bind the nation’s wounds.”  This healing of the nation fell to Lincoln’s successor Andrew Johnson and to Congress. After the war, many questions arose about the reconstruction of the Union. What would happen to 4,000,000 freed slaves? How would former Confederate states rejoin Congress? Who would govern those states—ex-Confederates? Northerners? Freedmen? Slavery had ended, but the struggle for equal rights continued. How the nation healed and its future direction depended on which fork in the road the country took. The paths chosen in the post-war era called “Reconstruction” continue to impact us today.
             Johnson served as Vice-president for only six weeks before Lincoln was murdered. Born in North Carolina in 1808, Johnson worked as a tailor as a young adult. He lacked a formal education but learned how to read and write from his wife, Eliza McCardle. He entered local politics in 1829 as an alderman and then as mayor of Greeneville, Tennessee moving later to state offices.
From humble roots, Johnson championed populist policies and resented the elite. He believed (as most politicians of the time) in limited federal government. He also strongly supported the Constitution, and at first, believed that it guaranteed the right to own slaves. In fact, Johnson owned slaves as had many previous presidents.
An early Johnson family house in Greeneville.
In the 1840s, Johnson went to Washington as a U.S. Representative and then returned to Tennessee as Governor. As the nation moved to war, he was elected as a U.S. Senator and during the war, became military governor of the state supporting the North. He joined Lincoln’s re-election bid in 1864 as vice-president from the Democratic Party in a symbol of national unity.
            After the Civil War, Johnson adopted Lincoln’s moderate approach to Reconstruction. He granted amnesty to Confederate soldiers and welcomed southern states back into the Union after 10% of those who voted in 1860 swore allegiance to the Constitution. These state governments, often with ex-Confederate leaders, began to approve laws which repressed newly freed slaves and institutionalized inequality. Johnson also wanted all land confiscated by the Union Army and given to the ex-slaves returned to its prewar owners. Johnson initiated his Presidential Reconstruction while Congress was in recess.
            Reconstruction did not mean rebuilding the South: it meant rebuilding the Union – politically not economically. For Johnson (and many Southerners), they wanted the South to be allowed freedom to move on. The Republicans in Congress (and many Northerners) wanted reform, even punishment, for the rebellious South. 
Anti-Johnson political cartoon about Reconstruction. (From exhibit at Johnson NHS)
As victors, “Republicans believed the defeated Southern states were territories to be ruled over until certain conditions were met, including the abolishment of slavery, the granting of civil rights to blacks, and the establishment of solid political control by the Republican Party.”[1] Johnson, not a Republican and not a Northerner, refused to compromise with them. The relationship between the President and Congress grew hostile.
Congress moved in a different direction by creating the Freedmen’s Bureau and passing the nation’s first Civil Rights Bill. Begun in 1865, the Bureau fed millions of people, provided medical care for ex-slaves, settled labor disputes, assisted former slaves in legalizing their marriages, and helped black veterans return to civilian life. It also aided in building thousands of schools for African Americans as well as in founding the universities of Howard, Fisk, and Hampton.
A school classroom for ex-slave children. (From exhibit at Johnson NHS)
          Congress also passed the Civil Rights Bill of 1866 which mandated that “all persons born in the United States and not subject to any foreign power, excluding Indians not taxed, are hereby declared to be citizens of the United States…”[2] Johnson vetoed this bill as well as the extension of the Freedmen’s Bureau in 1866, stating that they violated state’s rights, privileged one group of citizens over another, and would be expensive to implement. Congress overrode Johnson’s vetoes and ended up passing the 14th Amendment in 1866 that granted citizenship to African Americans.
          The electoral campaigns of 1866 produced a wave election, rewarding the Radical Republicans with majorities in both houses. They continued to enact their own “Radical Reconstruction.” Eight hundred African American men won elections to southern state houses and even to Congress.[3]
In February 1869, Congress approved the 15th Amendment which guaranteed that the right to vote could not be denied “on account of race, color, or previous condition of servitude.” This was an ambitious attempt to restructure Southern society by thwarting the reestablishment of a caste system, protecting ex-slaves from a return to peonage, and empowering blacks with civil and voting rights. Upon its ratification in April 1870, Frederick Douglass wrote in the New York Times: “We were always men. Now we are citizens and men among men.”[4]
As Reconstruction swept through the South, opportunists came calling. The exhibit at the Andrew Johnson NHS Visitors’ Center notes: “Northerners who moved to the Southern states and served as political leaders during the federal occupation of the South—the carpetbaggers—gained a reputation for corruption and aroused the bitter hostility of native whites.”[5] Scalawags (white Southerners who worked with the Republicans on Reconstruction) also gained notoriety. Most white Southerners blamed the carpetbaggers and scalawags among them for the crushing debt, falling land values, and destitution of the defeated South.
            The relationship between Johnson and Congress grew even more hostile when in March 1868, the House of Representatives impeached the President. Charged with eleven high crimes and misdemeanors, he was particularly accused of violating the “Tenure of Office Act” when he suspended the Secretary of War Stanton for opposing the Presidential Reconstruction policies. That May, the Senate acquitted Johnson of all charges by one vote (seven Republicans voted for acquittal). All of them suffered defeats in their next election. Johnson failed to gain the Democratic nomination for president and returned to Greeneville after his term ended in 1869. He died there in 1875.
Radical Reconstruction had achieved much in reforming the South – it built the region’s first state-funded public schools, enacted laws against discrimination in public transportation and housing, and created a more balanced tax system. But Radical Reconstruction lost its way in the partisan politics of trying to remove a sitting president. For the first time since the establishment of the Constitution (which provided the legal means to remove a president), Congress tried to use that provision to get rid of an unpopular executive.
            Then the tide turned as the South took a different fork in the road as progress toward integration of African Americans into society slowed and then reversed itself. By 1870, all the former Confederate states had regained their statehood status, and southern white supremacists began to push back. White and black Republican politicians in the South faced growing hostility from the newly created Ku Klux Klan, White League, and other extremist groups.
Political cartoon depicting fate of ex-slaves as "worse than slavery." (From exhibit at Johnson NHS)
As early as 1868 in Georgia, the KKK intimidated voters with murder, violence, and armed presences at polling stations. As a result, in that year, only one person in Columbia County voted for General Grant for president.[6] Violence and laws restricting black access to the voting booth in parts of the South disenfranchised freed slaves. By 1874, Democrats (aided by those elected from the South) regained control of the U.S. House of Representatives for the first time since the Civil War. Racial violence continued as between 1882 and 1930, over 3,000 black men and women lost their lives by lynching.[7]
Reconstruction ended in 1876 when a disputed presidential election was settled by a compromise. Democrat Samuel J. Tilden won the popular vote over Republican Rutherford B. Hayes but the contested votes in the Electoral College (mainly from Florida, Louisiana, and South Carolina) led to a dispute about who actually won. The Compromise of 1877 awarded Hayes the presidency if the Army ended its occupation of those three contested Southern states (the federal troops had already departed from the others) and if the federal government ended Reconstruction.
Why did the North abandon their reform efforts in the South? Partially, fatigue had set in. Often, the ardor of reform burns bright initially and then fades. When it did, the South reverted to its former ways as much as possible. Additionally, many Northerners did not support full civil rights for African Americans. Racism ran deep in the North as well as the South. Finally, as the North industrialized after the Civil War, other issues and events pushed Reconstruction aside as the country navigated through the Gilded Age.  
To better understand the fork in the road that the nation took right after the Civil War, I drove to the Andrew Johnson NHS in Greeneville, Tennessee, the home of the 17th president. One of the joys of teaching public history is to see a graduate of the program working at a historic site. Stephanie Steinhorst, Chief of Interpretation and Education at the Johnson site, earned her Masters at New Mexico State University and has worked for the NPS ever since. She carved out an afternoon in her schedule to give me a tour of the place and to talk about the man and the decisions that altered our country’s history. She first showed me Johnson’s tailor shop, a log cabin encased in the Visitors’ Center and then across the street, we saw the early Johnson home, including a basement kitchen where slaves labored. Next, we walked a couple of blocks to the Johnson Homestead, a red two-story brick house with a wrap-around porch. During the war, his home was used as a hospital by both sides.
At the Homestead, Stephanie acknowledged the tarnished reputation of Johnson. He did free slaves while military governor of Tennessee, but he also vetoed the extension of the Freedmen’s Bureau. Even though his Presidential Reconstruction favored the South, he is seen as a traitor there for running on the ticket with Lincoln. During the war, his family fled to Nashville under threat of getting lynched. Stephanie thought that Johnson would be more popular today with those who call for a strict adherence to the Constitution. As with most historic figures, he’s complicated.
While she showed me the second floor of the Johnson Homestead, she pointed to two photos of Yosemite hung on the landing. These early photos of Yosemite, taken by Amon Watkins, were shown to Lincoln in 1864. Afterwards, he signed an executive order that transferred the valley to California for management “upon the express conditions that the premises shall be held for public use, resort and recreation.” Stephanie exclaimed: “I love these. They are the start of the Park Service, and we have them hung right here.” Lincoln paved the way for the creation of the park system even in the midst of the Civil War.
Stephanie with Watkins' Yosemite photos.
The last stop on Stephanie’s tour was the Andrew Johnson National Cemetery. On a sharp hill south of town, a tall marble monument topped by an eagle taking off (or landing) marks his grave. The NPS manages the cemetery which holds not just Johnson and his family, but others from the community, including many veterans.
Johnson's grave at Greeneville.
Soon after the war, Southern writers shifted the causes of the Civil War from the protection of slavery and white supremacy to the Lost Cause, to States’ rights, and to resistance of Northern aggression. For these Southerners, the Confederacy embodied key elements of the American character-- a revolution by an underdog against a more powerful foe (just like the American Revolution), a cry for freedom to do what they wanted (guaranteed by the Constitution), and the obligation to secede from what they saw as a corrupt government (as required by the Declaration of Independence).
For most supporters of the Lost Cause, slavery did not figure into the narrative. In a country that declared equality and liberty in its founding document, how could owning another human be something that an ancestor fought and even died for? As historian John Keegan observes: “Indeed, the causes of the war are now its least remembered ingredients.”[8]
Here’s the fork in the road. The end of Reconstruction led to black Republicans losing power and the creation of a segregated society. Segregation in the South intensified at the end of the 19th century, culminating with laws which discriminated against blacks in housing, transportation, and voting. In 1890 at the Mississippi constitutional convention, delegates declared their purpose: “It is the manifest intention of this convention to secure to the state of Mississippi ‘white supremacy’.”[9] These “Jim Crow” laws across the South transformed informal separation which arose after the war to legal segregation. Perhaps Lincoln could have navigated the road blocks and detours of Reconstruction better than Johnson. Probably Lincoln would have taken a different fork in the road.

The legalization of segregation was approved by the U.S. Supreme Court in 1896 with Plessy v. Ferguson which established the policy of “Separate but Equal” in schools, transportation, and other aspects of public life. So, while some short term gains occurred in civil rights immediately after the war, the South instituted a variety of laws and policies backed up by violence that relegated Freedmen and women to second class citizenship and enforced white supremacy. In the long run, Reconstruction failed to create a more equal society. We now head west to explore a different way that the country rebuilt itself after the Civil War.

In 1935, Congress authorized the Andrew Johnson National Monument which became a National Historic Site in 1963.[10]
A Park Ranger mannequin in front of the Johnson house participating in Greeneville's Halloween contest.

All materials in this blog are copyrighted © 2020 by Jon Hunner.




[1] Exhibit text, Visitors’ Center, Johnson NHS, October 2016.

[2] https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Civil_Rights_Act_of_1866

[3] Jill Lepore, These Truths: A History of the United States (New York: W.W. Norton & Company, 2018), 323.

[4] Frederick Douglass, New York Times, April 11, 1870, quoted in “We Were Always Men,” Henry Louis Gates Jr., New York Times, April 10, 2020 on the amendment’s 150th anniversary.

[5] Exhibit text, Visitors’ Center, Johnson NHS, visited October 2016.

[6] http://www.georgiaencyclopedia.org/articles/history-archaeology/ku-klux-klan-reconstruction-era

[7] Lepore, These Truths, 330.

[8] John Keegan, The American Civil War: A Military History (New York: Alfred A Knopf, 2009), 356.

[9] “Loser take all: Jim Crow still haunts the Magnolia State’s politics,” The Economist, 11/2/2019, 41.


[10] Andrew Johnson National Historic Site  -- https://www.nps.gov/anjo.

No comments:

Post a Comment