Saturday, May 2, 2020

Exit 35 – The High Water Mark of the Confederacy at the Chancellorsville Unit of the Fredericksburg and Spotsylvania National Military Park and Gettysburg National Military Park, Virginia and Pennsylvania


             After the winter camps of 1862-63, the two armies came out bruising for a fight. Lee’s Army of Northern Virginia had consistently whipped the Army of the Potomac in Virginia, but had failed in its invasion of the North. Lincoln still sought a capable commander of his army able to aggressively pursue and beat the rebels. A decisive battle for the control of the East loomed.
            That May, in the woods of the Fredericksburg and Spotsylvania National Military Park (known as the Wilderness for its dense undergrowth), Lee won his greatest victory. His 60,000 men, half the size of the Union troops, soundly trounced General Joseph Hooker’s army.
On May 2, Lee sent half of his army commanded by Stonewall Jackson on a twelve-mile march west around the Union front line to attack its right flank. Union scouts detected the movement, but their generals thought that the rebels were retreating in the face of their superior forces. Surprised with the attack at the end of the day, Union forces staggered back.
Fierce fighting continued the next day as both sides contested the strategic crossroads. Eventually, Hooker ordered his troops to fall back behind the Rappahannock River on May 6. Three thousand soldiers had died in the battle with 20,000 wounded.
Despite the victory, it turned into a serious setback for Lee and his army. Stonewall Jackson, returning from a forward reconnaissance at dusk on May 2, was shot by his own troops. Jackson’s aides dragged his shattered body to an aid station where surgeons amputated his left arm but he died on May 10 from pneumonia uttering these last words: “Let us cross over the river and rest under the shade of the trees.”
Jackson dying in bed. (From exhibit at Fredericksburg & Spotsylvania County Battlefields Memorial NMP)
I drove to Chancellorsville Battlefield in central Virginia and visited the spot where North Carolina soldiers mistook Jackson for the enemy. The dense woods are quiet along the path a short distance from the Visitors’ Center, but I could imagine the soldiers (close to Union lines) firing at shadowy men on horses who surged toward them through the darkening woods.
Path through woods where Jackson was shot by his own troops.
So even though Chancellorsville was Lee’s greatest victory, he could not replace his greatest general who famously said: “I always have one single, simple opinion… and that is to attack the enemy wherever we find him.”[1] Lee’s generals never quite recovered from this victory at Chancellorsville.
Of the over 300 named battles of the Civil War, almost everyone knows about Gettysburg. At the beginning of July 1863, after over two years of brutal combat and horrendous losses, the two armies collided in the rolling hills in south central Pennsylvania. The might of 64,000 Confederates bore down on the small town of Gettysburg and clashed with 99,000 Union troops.
Lee invaded the North for the same reasons he had done so the previous year—to rattle the Union, to take pressure off of Virginia and Richmond, to reap the abundant supplies there, and to make the case for international recognition. And while the Army of Northern Virginia had successfully protected Richmond, Lee wanted to break out of the defensive war he waged and inflict a devastating defeat on the Union. If this happened, perhaps Lincoln and the North would negotiate for peace.
Lee's and Meade's routes to Gettysburg. (From exhibit at Gettysburg NMP)
On June 3, the Confederate army left the Chancellorsville area and began marching up the Shenandoah Valley. In response, General Hooker moved north, keeping his troops between the Southerners and Washington, D.C. Rebel cavalry led by General Jeb Stuart dashed behind Union forces, lost contact with Lee around June 25, approached D.C. on June 28, and then headed north. The absence of Lee’s cavalry (who could have provided him with information about the disposition and strength of Union troops), deprived him of vital intelligence when he needed it the most.
            Lee also suffered from fighting at a place not of his choosing. As the two large armies pivoted around each other in southern Pennsylvania, Lee chose Cashtown as his most advantageous location for the upcoming fight. A chance encounter led to the battle taking place at Gettysburg instead.
Near here west of Gettysburg, the two armies bumped into each other.
            On July 1, several brigades of General A.P. Hill’s troops approached Gettysburg from the west to capture a supply of badly needed boots rumored to be stockpiled in the town. They encountered Union cavalry instead and as the official handbook of the park states: “Thus the subordinate field commanders had chosen the ground for battle.”[2] What did the battleground look like?
            Gettysburg sits at the base of Cemetery and Culp Hills with the high ground extending south along Cemetery Ridge. This ridge terminates several miles away at Big and Little Round Tops. Parallel to Cemetery Ridge and about a mile to the west lies Seminary Ridge. The South took over Seminary Ridge.
While both sides saw advantages in the field for their success, Lee had to attack and so ultimately Northern troops had the better defensive positions. Still, the Confederates could have won. At several points, they came close to victory.
            After the initial encounter west of Gettysburg, the small forces of the two sides tested each other with some morning successes by Union cavalry who had rapid firing carbines. Both armies rushed soldiers to town, and fighting at times grew fierce. Confederate reinforcements led by General Early shattered the Union line, who retreated fighting through the streets of Gettysburg and onto Cemetery Hill. By 5 p.m., “the remnants of the Union forces (some 6,000 out of the 18,000 engaged in the first day’s battle) were on the hills south of Gettysburg.”[3]
Lee had arrived at the battlefield a couple of hours earlier and saw the ragged retreat of the Union soldiers. He ordered his troops to take Cemetery Hill. But the soldiers of General Dick Ewell (the new commander of Stonewall Jackson’s reorganized Second Corps) had suffered 8,000 casualties during the day and were too exhausted to press their advantage. Union forces on top of Cemetery Hill dug in during the night. Fresh Confederate reinforcements arrived later that evening, but this opportunity to capture the high ground was lost to the South.
Unbeknownst to Lee and his generals (because Stuart’s cavalry was still away), General Meade had rushed his own troops to Gettysburg. That night, they consolidated their lines extending from Culp’s and Cemetery Hills south along Cemetery Ridge to the hills of Big and Little Round Top. The Union had secured a three-mile front shaped like a fish hook and with it, high ground and interior lines.
Positions of the two armies' position with the town at the top of the map. (From exhibit at Gettysburg NMP)
Lee decided to attack the Union forces on their flanks on July 2. His soldiers crashed against entrenched Union defenses on Cemetery Hill like storm waves against a rocky shore. Its steep slope aided Union troops in repelling the hard charging Confederates, and so the South gained little ground there.
At the south end of the battlefield, General James Longstreet’s troops came close to turning their enemies’ flank. If they could capture the high ground at Little Round Top and place artillery there, they could sweep the Union line along Cemetery Ridge with devastating enfilading fire and unhinge their defenses. Confederates advanced through the Peach Orchard, the Wheat Field, the Devil’s Den, and onto the western slopes of Big Round Top with dead and wounded men strewn in their wake.
Meade’s Chief of Engineers, General G. K. Warren, arrived at Little Big Top to survey the Union’s left flank. To his dismay, he discovered that the movement of troops responding to the Confederates’ advances had left this position devoid of any forces except a signal unit. Warren realized that if Longstreet’s men struck, they could easily occupy this key Union position.
Looking down on the battlefield from Little Round Top. Notice the white domed monument on the right which marks the Union's position on Cemetery Ridge.
Federal reserves already moving forward rushed to fill the gap. A pivotal moment for the battle and in fact, the whole war, now took place. A thin line of Union forces fought off waves of two regiments of Alabama soldiers. Col. Joshua Chamberlain led his 20th Maine in the defense and as their ammunition ran out, ordered a bayonet charge downhill which scattered the surprised rebels. At the end of the second day of heavy fighting which lasted until 10 p.m., the South had come close to breaking the Union defenses, but had not quite done it. Lee felt sure that the next day would bring victory.
Looking east from Seminary Ridge across the field that Pickett's men would have to charge. Notice again the white domed monument in the distance above the cannon which marks the Union line on Cemetery Ridge.
Confident that his troops could beat the Yankees in a frontal assault, he ordered 15,000 men to attack the middle of the Union line. Longstreet disagreed with Lee, telling him: “General, I have been a soldier all my life… and should know, as well as anyone what soldiers can do. It is my opinion that no 15,000 men ever arrayed for battle can take that position.”[4] Nonetheless, Lee ordered the attack.
From exhibit at Gettysburg NMP.
Map of Pickett's Charge. (From exhibit at Gettysburg NMP)
The high water mark of the Confederacy, the closest that the Rebels got to the top of Cemetery Ridge protected by the Union cannons.
General George Pickett’s troops, fresh from guarding the supply train, moved into position to lead the attack. After an artillery barrage, Longstreet could only nod when asked if his troops should advance. He did not trust his voice with the command. Across the almost mile wide plain separating Seminary Ridge from Cemetery Ridge, Southerners charged through heavy artillery fire to assault the entrenched Union line. Pickett’s Charge failed with almost 50 percent casualties while among its officers, 80 percent were either killed or wounded. When Lee met Pickett as he stumbled back from the assault, he told him: “Your men have done all that men can do. The fault is certainly my own.”
Scene from Pickett's Charge, painted by Paul Philippoteaux. (From cyclorama at Gettysburg Visitors' Center)
Lee’s army retreated to Virginia and while Meade’s troops followed them, Union troops could not rally themselves to engage in another battle that might have crushed the Army of Northern Virginia. Limping back to Confederate territory, Lee and the South heard of the fall of Vicksburg. This Union victory secured the Mississippi River for the North and spotlighted Grant as a general who defeated the enemy. Lincoln took notice.
During the Battle of Gettysburg, the Army of Northern Virginia lost 22,600 men killed (4,559), wounded (12,355), or missing (5,643), while the Army of the Potomac lost about 22,800 men killed (3,149), wounded (14,501), or missing (5,157).[5] So, over 45,000 soldiers were casualties out of the total of 163,000 massed for the battle. On July 7, the Gettysburg Compiler wrote about the casualty list: “Every name… is a lightning stroke to some heart, and breaks like thunder over some home, and falls a long black shadow upon some hearthstone.”[6]
            What happened to those soldiers who died on the battlefield? At Gettysburg as at Antietam, Union dead were quickly removed and buried—often in new cemeteries nearby. Confederate dead were not so well served. Northerners had little time nor patience to bury the enemy. In fact, as Lee’s troops marched to Gettysburg, some went through Antietam and saw the exposed skeletons of those countrymen who had fallen a year earlier. Eventually, Southern women searched for and buried Confederate dead, but some remains at Gettysburg took nine years to return to the South. Additionally, 5,000 horses also died during the battle and were burned to stop the rotting.[7]
             On November 19, 1863, at the dedication of Gettysburg’s cemetery for fallen Union troops, Lincoln gave one of his most cherished speeches—the Gettysburg Address. With the stench of death still hanging over the town, Lincoln said:
           
Four score and seven years ago, our fathers brought forth on this continent a new nation: conceived in liberty, and dedicated to the proposition that all men are created equal. Now we are engaged in a great civil war, testing whether that nation, or any nation so conceived and so dedicated, can long endure. We are met on a great battlefield of that war.
We have come to dedicate a portion of that field as a final resting place for those who here gave their lives that that nation might live. It is altogether fitting and proper that we should do this.
But, in a larger sense, we cannot dedicate, we cannot consecrate, we cannot hallow this ground. The brave men, living and dead, who struggled here have consecrated it, far above our poor power to add or detract. The world will little note, nor long remember, what we say here, but it can never forget what they did here.
It is for us the living, rather, to be dedicated here to the unfinished work which they who fought here have thus far so nobly advanced. It is rather for us to be here dedicated to the great task remaining before us, that from these honored dead we take increased devotion to that cause for which they gave the last full measure of devotion, that we here highly resolve that these dead shall not have died in vain, that this nation, under God, shall have a new birth of freedom and that government of the people, by the people, for the people shall not perish from the earth.

In two minutes and with 272 words, Lincoln tapped the core of the Civil War – to preserve the democracy of the Union – that still resonates today.
Lincoln with Union troops. (From exhibit at Gettysburg NMP)
            As I drove out of my RV campsite near Gettysburg, I met two women from Houston in their motorhome. We talked about how we were touring NPS sites—their goal was to hit all 400+ units. I asked them what we should call ourselves—park fanatics? NPS voyagers? Up to then, I did not have a good name for those of us who were driven by the parks. And then it came to me—parkgonauts. Like Argonauts, like astronauts, like cosmonauts, we journey into the parks, looking for human and natural wonders. I had met many members of our tribe during my road trip. Now I knew what to call us.

The Battle of Gettysburg in the summer of 1863 was the high water mark of the Confederates’ invasion of the North. Even though Lee and his army came close to victory, they failed for several reasons. Lee was unaware of what Meade’s troops were doing since his cavalry was out of contact. Lee did not pick the best battlefield. He believed that his hard charging soldiers could whip the Yankees despite the advice of Longstreet. The end of the Civil War remained several years away, but after Gettysburg, the South struggled to defend its capitol at Richmond and counter Union advances in the West and South. After Gettysburg, the South played defense. 

In 1864, the Gettysburg Battlefield Memorial Association began to preserve the history of the battle. In 1895, Congress authorized Gettysburg as a National Military Park managed by the War Department.[8] Fredericksburg and Spotsylvania became National Military Parks in 1927.[9] President Franklin Roosevelt transferred all of these National Military Parks to the National Park Service in June 1933.
Confederate re-enactor on Seminary Ridge. When I asked him why he was there, he replied "So people know what happened here.

All materials in this blog are copyrighted © 2020 by Jon Hunner.



[1] Exhibit text at Chancellorsville Battlefield Visitors’ Center, visited September 2016.


[3] Ibid., 24.

[4] Exhibit text at Gettysburg’s Visitors’ Center, visited September 2016.

[5] Ibid.

[6] Ibid.

[7] From tour of Gettysburg cemetery by Volunteer Joan, September 2016; Jill Lepore, These Truths: A History of the United States (New York: W.W. Norton & Company, 2018), 294.

[8] Gettysburg National Military Park -- https://www.nps.gov/gett.


[9] Fredericksburg and Spotsylvania National Military Park -- https://www.nps.gov/frsp.

No comments:

Post a Comment