Monday, May 4, 2020

Exit 37 – End Game at Fredericksburg and Spotsylvania County Battlefields Memorial National Military Park and at Petersburg National Battlefield, Virginia



             After three years of battles in the East, the two armies stood in almost the same positions as when war began. To break the stalemate, Lincoln appointed a new general to force the end of the war. The depleted Southern army needed to defend Richmond at all costs while playing for time to thwart Lincoln’s re-election and hope for a negotiated peace with a new president.
In March 1864, Grant took command of all the Union armies and started planning to march on Richmond. Lee knew that if Grant’s forces crossed the James River and got south of Richmond, a siege ending in defeat would follow. Near the place where Stonewall Jackson died at the Battle of Chancellorsville a year earlier, the two armies clashed at the beginning of the Overland Campaign.
Grant brought a different tactic to his army. Up to now, most soldiers fought in one or two major battles a season. As noted at the Chancellorsville Visitors’ Center: “Prior to then, a typical soldier might have been under fire for ten hours in a year.  At Spotsylvania, some were under fire for ten hours in a single day.”[1] Grant’s army relentlessly attacked Lee’s forces at The Wilderness, Spotsylvania Courthouse, North Anna, and Cold Harbor between May 5 and June 12. A new type of war swept over Virginia.
The Overland Campaign. (From exhibit at Chancellorsville unit of Fredericksburg and Spotsylvania County Battlefields Memorial National Military Park)
On May 4, the Army of the Potomac crossed the Rapidan River and engaged Lee’s army. Grant had 122,000 soldiers against Lee’s 66,000; however, dense woods took away the North’s numerical advantage and rendered Union artillery almost useless. Lee had chosen his battlefield well.
            On May 5, fighting grew fierce as Lee threw his full force into battle. Men grappled in hand-to-hand combat and battle lines grew confused as they surged back and forth in the thick forest. The next day, shooting erupted at dawn. Probing Union soldiers found a weak spot where Confederates had failed to entrench, but at the last moment, General Longstreet’s troops arrived and beat back the Northerners.
            Taking the offensive, Longstreet used a railroad cut to sneak four brigades around and attack the Union left flank. Then, five miles from where Stonewall Jackson was shot, Longstreet was also struck by a bullet from his own troops. He survived, but his advance faltered, giving Union troops time to regroup and repulse renewed attacks. That night, both sides heard the cries from the wounded, some 200 or more incinerated by fires sparked by the fighting that swept through the Wilderness.
Remains of dead soldiers in the Wilderness. (From exhibit at Chancellorsville unit)
Both sides staggered under their losses. The North had 2,246 killed, 12,037 wounded, and 3,383 missing while the South had casualties between 7,500 and 11,000 (precise numbers are hard to come by). Past Union generals had recoiled from such losses. Not Grant. As historian James McPherson writes: “For the first time in a Virginia campaign the Army of the Potomac stayed on the offensive after its initial battle.”[2] Grant’s army tried to slide around Lee’s right flank to capture the strategic crossroads at the Spotsylvania Courthouse, the most direct route to Richmond.
Lee guessed Grant’s move. He told a subordinate: “He will move his army to Spotsylvania…. I am so sure of his next move that I have already made arrangements to march by the shortest practical route, so that we may meet him there.”[3] Confederates won the race to the Courthouse where they fortified their lines with trenches and breastworks.
Skirmishing began on May 8 as both sides dug in. On May 9, an able Union corps commander, General John Sedgwick, died from a Confederate sniper just after he said: “They couldn’t hit an elephant at this distance.”[4] The next day, the fighting began in earnest.
The focal point of the Battle of Spotsylvania Courthouse was a line of breastworks that bulged north of the Confederate fortifications called the Mule Shoe Salient. Here one of the bloodiest days and most intense hand-to-hand fighting of the entire war occurred.
Battle of Spotsylvania Courthouse. (From Chancellorsville unit)
On May 10, 4,000 Union soldiers four lines deep attacked the breastworks. The front line, not firing until they reached the trenches, breached Confederate defenses. Fanning out left and right, they widened the breach while the second line rushed through and attacked the second network of trenches 100 yards to the rear. The third and fourth line entered the salient and rounded up prisoners. But with weak support, Union soldiers retreated in face of determined counterattacks.
Mule Shoe Salient. (From exhibit at Chancellorsville unit)
On May 12, Grant ordered a similar advance with 15,000 troops which gained similar success. Lee rode to the front to lead the desperate resistance but his men cried out “General Lee to the rear!” The South had lost too many of its valued officers. Lee relented as the counterattack forced Northerners back to the toe of Mule Shoe Salient. Thousands of Union and Confederate soldiers now fought viciously for hours over a 200-yard front, known now as the Bloody Angle.
McPherson describes the fighting: “Blood flowed as copiously as the rain, turning trench floors into a slimy ooze where dead and wounded were trampled down by men fighting for their lives. ‘I never expect to be fully believed when I tell what I saw of the horrors of Spotsylvania,’ wrote a Union officer, ‘because I should be loath to believe it myself were the case reversed’.”[5] A Union soldier simply said: “This has been the most terrific day I have ever lived.”[6]
After nightfall, Lee ordered his men out of the salient. Grant lost 17,500 at Spotsylvania and a total of 33,000 so far in the Overland Campaign. Lee’s causalities at Spotsylvania was 12,500 for a total of over 20,000 for the month. More death loomed ahead.
Grant’s next flanking movement marched his soldiers twenty-five miles south to a railroad junction near the North Anna River. Lee again correctly anticipated Grant and thwarted the attempt to capture this junction. Grant then ordered his army to a dusty crossroads near Richmond called Cold Harbor. Lee’s forces again arrived first and fortified a seven-mile long concave front anchored at its ends by the Totopotomoy Creek and the Chickahominy River. By now, the Confederates had mastered the art of defensive earthworks and created zig-zag trenches, strong breastworks, and spiked abatis.
Several days of heavy skirmishing punctuated Cold Harbor in early June. Union General Horace Porter, walking among his troops, noticed that his men were pinning their names on the back of their uniforms, “so that their dead bodies might be recognized and their fate known to their families at home.”[7] After a month of fighting and dying, Northern soldiers expected the worst.
On June 2, the first wave marched towards Confederate breastworks, only to face a withering fire. Union soldiers breached parts of the defenses, but withdrew under a ferocious counterattack. 7,000 Federal troops fell dead or wounded. Grant ordered a second general assault with the same results. After that, he ordered a third charge but this one was largely ignored by his weary troops. Later that night, Grant lamented: “I regret this assault more than any one I have ever ordered.”[8]
Perhaps Grant was finally shocked by his casualties. Over three days at Cold Harbor, Union losses totaled 12,000. The South’s losses equaled 5,000. Union General Evander Law commented that this was “not war but murder.”[9] For the entire Overland Campaign, Union casualties amounted to 55,000 while Confederates lost about 33,000 killed, wounded, and missing. Grant’s soldiers had closed on Richmond, but at a tremendous cost.
On June 12, Grant once more moved to his left, this time crossing the James River on a hastily built pontoon bridge and swinging around to threaten Petersburg, the back door to Richmond. He hoped to cut off Richmond by severing its last railroads to the rest of the South.
On a rainy September afternoon, I spent the afternoon at Petersburg National Battlefield. Ranger Christopher led parkonaut Kath from Maryland and me in an in-depth tour of the site. A torrential downpour drenched the three of us, but did not dampen our spirits. Christopher told us that around Petersburg from June 1864 to April 1865, enemies clashed 108 times including nine major battles.
Ranger Christopher talking about the siege of Petersburg at the Dimmock Line.
The campaign began on June 15, when General R.B. Smith troops’ attacked the sparsely defended Dimmock Line with 15,000 men. Along that ten-mile long front,  Confederates had only 2,500 defenders. The Confederates built the Line with earthen walls fourteen feet tall and ten to fifteen feet thick. The entire Line circled around Petersburg and Richmond for almost forty miles, a formidable barrier.
At 11 a.m., the Union soldiers first saw the Dimmock Line from a mile away. After Cold Harbor, neither Smith nor his men wanted to assault such a daunting fortification. Smith’s men finally started attacking at 7 p.m., and by 9 p.m., Union troops had breached the Line.
The Dimmock Line toady at the Petersburg NB Visitors' Center.
Smith called it a day, and Lee rushed in 45,000 reinforcements overnight. Experts say that the Union could have defeated the Army of Northern Virginia then if Smith had started earlier and been more aggressive. As at other battles throughout the war, a delayed attack at the beginning of a battle lost an early victory. At Petersburg, the delay extended the war by 292 days with tens of thousands more casualties.
Recreation of fortifications of the Dimmock Line including fraises.
As we drove through the woods, Christopher pointed out where the U.S. Army trained its soldiers during World War I for trench warfare in France. Christopher then stopped at Confederate Battery 9 where a recreation of a siege encampment illustrates the tactics of fortified entrenchments. At the reconstruction, we saw how gabions (willow baskets filled with dirt and rocks) were used to build the wall which was topped by a parapet of sandbags and timber. Deadly fraises (sharpened stakes and logs sticking out from the base of the Line) slowed any attack on the walls. Against such robust defenses, Union officers and enlisted men at times mutinied and refused to assault the Dimmock Line. Despite earthen walls providing protection, Christopher mentioned how after weeks and months of bombardment and sniper fire, some Confederate soldiers cracked and stood on top of the bulwarks, begging to be killed.
Entrance to tunnel.

Next stop on the driving tour was the Crater. On June 17, Union soldiers attacked the Elliot Salient of the Line. Enemy fire halted them 400 feet from Confederate breastworks. To protect themselves, U.S. troops started digging, eventually making trenches six to eight feet deep. They refused to attack the next day but hunkered down and extended their trenches. Some of these troops had been miners, and they began a tunnel going towards the Confederates with the intention of detonating explosives under the Line. During the month of digging the 500-foot long shaft, a unit of U.S. Colored Troops trained to lead the first wave by charging around the perimeter of the crater. But then fearing repercussions if the attack failed and the black troops were slaughtered, at the last moment General Meade ordered white soldiers who had not been so trained into action instead.
The remains of the Crater.
At 4:45 a.m. on July 30, 900 pounds of explosives ripped a crater 170 feet long, 60 feet wide, and 30 feet deep. Over 300 Confederates died from the detonation. Into the breech, thousands of inadequately trained Union soldiers poured down the slopes of the smoking crater and penetrated several hundred yards behind the Confederates’ front line. Quickly regrouping, Confederates counterattacked, repulsed the Union advance, and then from the rim, fired into the mass of blue uniforms trapped in the Crater. For forty-five minutes, slaughter reigned. In all, Ranger Christopher said that 4,600 Union men died or were wounded in the Crater while Confederate losses totaled about 1,500 men.
As the fighting ground to a standstill and the armies went into winter quarters, the Army of the Potomac needed to feed, clothe, and supply its 100,000 soldiers. Logistics are a vital part of any war, and by 1864, the Union army knew how to take care of its men in the field. I stopped at City Point on the James River, which supplied the needs of the Union army. About five miles from the Dimmock Line, City Point lies on the deep channel of the river allowing ships to bring in supplies and take away the wounded.
The railyard at City Point. (From exhibit at Shiloh NMP)
For ten months in 1864-1865, City Point was the busiest port in the world.[10] Along its half mile of wharves, 1,500 tons of supplies arrived each day. Railroads spurs led to warehouses and then more tracks took supplies to the front lines. Bakeries baked 100,000 loaves of bread a day, and warehouses had enough food stockpiled for the entire army for thirty days. Supplies for the Confederate army came into Richmond from southern states.
Four military hospitals also took care of the wounded at City Point. At Depot Hospital, 1,000 tents spread out over 200 acres holding 10,000 patients with the most seriously wounded taken by ship to northern hospitals. The U.S. Sanitary Commission and the U.S. Christian Commission distributed items to patients and helped ease their pain.
Grant's cabin on the right, the Army's Quartermaster's house on the left at City Point.
Grant came to City Point early in the Petersburg campaign. He set up his headquarters there in a small log cabin on the banks overlooking the James River. He lived in the cabin for four months that winter, joined by his wife and son. Lincoln visited City Point in March of 1865 where he met with Grant, Sherman, and others to plan the end of the war. At the meeting, Lincoln insisted on lenient terms of surrender to help heal the nation. Lincoln also went to Depot Hospital and shook hands with 6,000 wounded soldiers from both sides recovering there.
Grant at his cabin at City Point. (From exhibit at City Point)
            More than 100,000 Union soldiers coiled around the Confederate capital that winter. Sherman’s army marched through the Carolinas on its way to join them for the final showdown with the Army of Northern Virginia. The end game of the Overland Campaign and the siege of Petersburg set up the Confederate defeat. We now drive to Appomattox Courthouse for the final chapter of combat. 

Congress authorized the creation of Petersburg National Battlefield in July 1926 and Fredericksburg and Spotsylvania County Battlefields Memorial National Military Park in February 1927.[11] Both were transferred from the War Department to the National Park Service in 1933.



All materials in this blog are copyrighted © 2020 by Jon Hunner.


[1] Exhibit text at Fredericksburg and Spotsylvania County Battlefields Memorial NMP Visitors’ Center, visited September 2016.
[2] James McPherson, Battle Cry of Freedom: The Civil War Era (New York: Oxford University Press, 1988), 728.
[3] John Bowman, editor, The Civil War Almanac (New York: W.H Smith Publishers, 1983), 198.
[4] Ibid., 199-200.
[5] McPherson, Battle Cry, 730-31.
[6] Bowman, Civil War Almanac, 201.
[7] Ibid., 206.
[8] Ibid., 207.
[9] John Keegan, The American Civil War: A Military History (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 2009), 247.
[10] Film at City Point, Petersburg National Battlefield, visited September 2016.
[11] Petersburg National Battlefield -- https://www.nps.gov/pete; Fredericksburg and Spotsylvania County Battlefields Memorial National Military Park  -- https://www.nps.gov/frsp.

No comments:

Post a Comment