Thursday, July 2, 2020

Exit 59 – A Fork in the Road: Cliocide


 This posting is in commemoration of the 75th anniversary of the first atomic explosion at the Trinity Site in New Mexico on July 16th, 1945. 
Replicas of the first two atomic bombs. Fat Man on top and Little Boy below. (From exhibit at the National Museum of Nuclear Science and History)
The number of people who died in World War II is shocking. Overall, perhaps as many 75,000,000 military personnel and civilians lost their lives around the globe. Civilians in both China and Russia suffered greatly from combat and famine as war ravaged their countries. In Europe, 6,000,000 Jews were murdered by Nazis in death camps, on streets, and in homes. Millions more civilians died in work camps, as slaves to the war machines of Germany and Japan. Defeating Germany and Japan, who brutally treated the people in the countries they occupied and killed inhabitants by the millions, made this a war for human rights.
            How to end the most horrific war in human history? In Europe, the Allies threw vast resources of men and materiel at Germany from the east, south, and west. Germany’s resolve crumbled as Allied troops attacked its homeland and devastated its cities and fields.
            Japan’s islands and peoples created a different challenge. An amphibious invasion of their home islands against a determined and resolved populace would be costly in men, equipment, and time. Many indications pointed to Japan resisting to the bitter end. After Victory in Europe (VE) in April 1945, how would the Allies secure one over Japan?
            Oddly enough, Germany provided the key. Before Nazis invaded Poland and launched the war in Europe, physicists Otto Hahn and Fritz Strassman in Berlin made a fateful discovery. In fall 1938, they bombarded a lump of uranium with neutrons which surprisingly to them, generated excess heat and created elements of boron. When they sent their puzzling findings to Lise Meitner, a Jewish colleague who had fled to Sweden, she and her nephew Otto Frisch realized that Hahn and Strassman had split the atom. Not knowing what to call it, they came up with “fission,” borrowed from biology.[1] No one knew how to pronounce the verb of fission so some pronounced it like “fishing.”
            Philosophers as far back as Greece had theorized  about an indivisible unit of matter which they called an atom. Einstein’s E=mc2 predicted that if an atom was divided, an enormous amount of energy would be released. Consequently, Hahn and Strassman’s discovery swept through the world of nuclear physics like a crown-jumping forest fire with the fear that Nazis were ahead in harnessing the power of the atom for military purposes.
            After England entered the war in 1939, research intensified in Great Britain, but in the U.S. little was done until Pearl Harbor. Then President Roosevelt ordered the Army Corps of Engineers to build an atom bomb under the code name Manhattan Project. General Leslie R. Groves, who had just overseen building the Pentagon, took command of the project and faced several vital decisions. First, where to locate the key facilities? The project needed a central research laboratory and places to manufacture the materials of an atomic weapon. Second, Groves needed to find a person to direct the laboratory where scientists, engineers, and munitions’ experts would experiment on creating an atomic explosion.
Oppenheimer on the right and Groves on the left. (In front of Fuller Lodge at Los Alamos)
            For the director, Groves chose Dr. J. Robert Oppenheimer, a distinguished theoretical physicist who taught at the University of California at Berkeley. Curiously, Oppie (as his friends and colleagues called him) had not even served as the administrative chair of his own Department of Physics. But Groves saw a drive in Oppie that more accomplished scientists lacked.
            Once Groves picked Oppie, they searched the West for a suitable location for the central research lab. Groves eventually chose Los Alamos, an exclusive boys’ school in the mountains of northern New Mexico. In December 1942, bulldozers started preparing the plateau for a top secret facility which changed human history.
            Oppie recruited Nobel Prize winning scientists, émigré physicists, graduate students, and many others to join his team at Los Alamos. Arriving in Spring  1943, they set about experimenting on how to create an atomic explosion. Essential to their work was nuclear material produced at Oak Ridge, Tennessee, and Hanford, Washington.
Map of Manhattan Project sites (From exhibit at American Museum of Science and Energy, Oakridge, TN)
To split an atom and create an explosion, atoms need to be slightly unstable, that is, they need to have an imbalance between their electrons and protons. Scientists identified two elements suitable for such work—Uranium and Plutonium. Oak Ridge, using massive centrifuges and microscopic filters, extracted from naturally occurring uranium ore (Uranium238) the rare isotope of Uranium235.
Making plutonium requires a different method. At Hanford, bombarding uranium ore by neutrons turned it into a totally man-made element, plutonium. At the Reach Museum in Hanford, docent and retired nuclear scientist Gary Busselman explained the process to me. Uranium rods weighing eight pounds each were irradiated at Reactor B, producing small spots of plutonium the size of a pen point.[2] A World War II atomic bomb needed around seventeen pounds of plutonium to explode. So, this nuclear process created a lot of radioactive waste.
Illustration of a chain reaction. (From exhibit at Hanford Reach Museum, Hanford, WA.)
Scientists at Los Alamos experimented with both uranium and plutonium to assemble a nuclear weapon. Using a traditional bomb concept, scientists focused on shooting a plug of Uranium235 into a larger amount of that isotope which released neutrons that split other atoms, creating a chain reaction, and an atomic explosion. The scientists nicknamed this bomb Little Boy.
This method did not work for plutonium, so the lab came up with an innovative technique—an implosion bomb. Scientists surrounded a core of plutonium with conventional explosives and detonated them at exactly the same time. The converging shock wave on the plutonium compressed the atoms, splitting off neutrons which caused more fissions, and released an explosive amount of energy. This device was called Fat Man.
Fat Man at Trinity Site, July 15, 1945. (From exhibit at AMSE, Oakridge)
By summer 1945, scientists prepared to test the plutonium bomb, but some worried about setting the atmosphere on fire with a run-away explosion and the end of humans on the earth. In ancient Greece, Clio was the muse of history. If the explosion got out of control, it could mean the death of history, thus Cliocide. Scientists were convinced that Little Boy would work, but not so sure about Fat Man. So they left Los Alamos to go fishing in the desert.
At 5:29 a.m. on July 16, 1945, Fat Man imploded in the desert of New Mexico. The flash from the blast lit up the pre-dawn sky, and people in New Mexico, Texas, Arizona, and Mexico witnessed it. At the closest observation posts 10,000 yards away, silence lasted for thirty seconds. Then, a shock wave knocked down anyone standing outdoors. A seismologist fifty miles away said it felt like an earthquake.
Many eyewitnesses to the first atomic explosion described the historic fireball. Joan Hinton, a graduate student in physics from Wisconsin, observed the blast from a hill twenty-five miles away: “It was like being at the bottom of an ocean of light. We were bathed in it from all directions. The light withdrew into the bomb as if the bomb sucked it up. Then it turned purple and blue and went up and up and up…. Then suddenly the sound reached us. It was very sharp and rumbled and all the mountains were rumbling with it.” One eyewitness looking at the rising mushroom cloud “saw the elephant” as he likened it to an elephant standing on its trunk.

Upper left, the Trinity explosion at .025 seconds after detonation. Above, the mushroom cloud at 15 seconds after the detonation. (From photos hung on fence at Trinity Site)
Chemist George Kistiakowsky speculated "that at the end of the world--in the last millisecond of the earth's existence--the last men will see what we saw." Test director Kenneth Bainbridge congratulated Oppie by stating: "Well, now we're all sons of bitches." After the luminous mushroom cloud rose like the sun, it dissipated, and then, the real sun rose. Some said they saw the sun rise twice that day.
Fat Man detonated with the equivalent force of eighteen tons of TNT. The massive industrial and scientific enterprise that created the three atomic bombs in 1945 employed more people than built vehicles during the war and cost $2,000,000,000. The remaining plutonium bomb and the uranium one headed to Japan to end the war.
The U.S. detonated the uranium atomic bomb over Hiroshima and the plutonium one over Nagasaki in August 1945. At both Japanese cities, thousands vaporized at the moment of detonation from the heat of the man-made suns, leaving only their shadows etched on sidewalks and buildings. Thousands more died from shock waves as buildings collapsed on them or debris from blown apart structures pierced them. Thousands more perished from the fire storms that ravaged the atomic landscapes for days after the detonations. Newspapers of the day reported that a single atomic bomb packed the equivalent destructive force of 2,000 fully loaded B-29 Superfortress bombers.
The mushroom cloud rising over Hiroshima, Aug. 6, 1945. (From exhibit at AMSE, Oakridge)
In addition to this quantum leap in destructive power, the bombs introduced a new lethality to the battlefields. At the moment of the explosion, gamma rays released from the splitting of the atoms radiated humans and burned their internal organs. These damaged organs failed to process the vital fluids necessary for life and people died, often taking weeks to painfully succumb. The atomic bombs also scattered unexploded uranium and plutonium in fallout and when breathed or ingested, deposited particles that could cause cancers and other health issues decades later.
Hiroshima’s death toll from the August 6 bombing totaled 60,000 to 70,000 dead while between 40,000 and 50,000 died from the August 9 Nagasaki explosion. Tens of thousands more people perished from the radiation exposure in the weeks and years that followed. These detonations from a devastating new weapon forced Japan to surrender.
Japanese survivors of the atomic bomb. (From exhibit at AMSE, Oakridge)
To be clear, the war against Japan had already been won. It had been won by the Allied soldiers and sailors, by factories on the home front, and by farmers in the hinterlands; however the atomic weapons ended the war that August. The atomic bombs made a costly invasion of the Japanese home islands unnecessary. Perhaps it took such a horrendous weapon to end the most horrific war in human history.
The Cold War between the U.S. and the Soviet Union and the resultant nuclear arms race created hydrogen bombs, some 1,000 more powerful than those used over Japan. The U.S. and the U.S.S.R. then had the ability to commit Cliocide or which became known as M.A.D. (Mutually Assured Destruction).
Since the end of the Cold War, the world has edged back from a nuclear Armageddon; however the environmental legacy of nuclear waste persists. For example, plutonium remains toxic for 240,000 years. Other radioactive elements such as Iodine131, Strontium90, and Cesium137 have shorter toxic lifespans but still can cause cancers. The Department of Energy (who operates the nuclear sites) spends billions to process the waste but struggles with how to get rid of such toxic material. 
Another legacy is how to preserve and understand this history? In November 2015, I participated in a Scholars’ Forum to help the NPS figure out how to interpret the newly created Manhattan Project National Historical Parks. For two days, some twenty-five atomic historians, community members, and staff from NPS, Department of Energy, and Army Corps of Engineers, as well as two representatives from Hiroshima and Nagasaki discussed how to present the history of the Manhattan Project.
We discussed the key elements needed to tell the story of the Manhattan Project, including scientific discoveries, the historical context of World War II, the destruction of the cities of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, nuclear environmental legacy, and the Cold War and its aftermath. The representatives from Japan’s Atomic Cities were not so interested in discussing the questions that atomic historians grapple with; however, they clearly stated several times (and produced letters from their mayors saying the same thing) that they hoped that visitors would come away from their encounter with the Manhattan Project NHP concluding “Never Again.” All of us at the table agreed with them. The interpretive plans for these parks continue to get refined.

The legacy of the Manhattan Project is manifold. It helped end World War II in August 1945, sparing numerous lives—both Allied military as well as the Japanese who would resist the invasion. Nuclear weapons then entered arsenals of some countries at large costs in funding and material. Even today, decades after the end of the Cold War, we spend billions on maintaining our nuclear stockpile. The environmental legacy of our nuclear weapons’ production continue to plague humans and will affect the earth for thousands of years to come.
            Since most of the U.S.’s nuclear facilities reside in the west, it helped transform that region into a pace-setter for the rest of the nation. It also attracted thousands of families to places where they might not have lived. My family is an example. After fighting in the Pacific, my father transferred to the atomic arm of the Air Force in the 1950s and for the rest of his career, worked to safeguard the bases where we stored nuclear weapons. As a result, I have lived in New Mexico most of my life.
The Cold War fueled by nuclear weapons drove post-war history. After all previous wars, the U.S. military reduced to a small force. Not so after World War II. Our military remained robust to counter the Soviets-- spawning what President Eisenhower warned about in his last speech as Commander in Chief—a military-industrial complex. Having nuclear weapons helped the United States create an “American Century” after the war and secured our place as a superpower.
Nonetheless, an unease prevailed. As CBS reporter Edward R. Murrow said: “Seldom if ever has a war ended leaving the victors with such a sense of uncertainty and fear.” Or as Fortune magazine asked: “We know what the bombs did to Hiroshima and Nagasaki. But what did they do to  the U.S. mind?”[3] Even though President Dwight Eisenhower presided over a build up of nuclear weapons in the 1950s, he worried about an atomic war: “There just aren’t enough bulldozers to scrape the bodies off the street.” Early in his presidency, he warned: “Every gun that is made, every warship launched, every rocket fired signifies in the final sense a theft from those who hunger and are not fed, those who are cold and not clothed.”[4]  
Missiles capable of delivering nuclear weapons. (From Missile Park at White Sands Missile Range Museum)
The innovations of the Manhattan Project continue to shape our lives with what Oppie called the promise and the peril of the atomic age. Today, 20% of U.S. electricity comes from nuclear plants, and in France, they depend on them for almost 75%. Nuclear medicine has transformed how we diagnose and treat a variety of our ills, from seeing inside our bodies to killing cancer cells. Historians in the future will look at the creation of nuclear weapons as perhaps the most important event in this century, rivaling human flight, the moon landing, and all the inventions of Edison—that is if we don’t commit Cliocide.

The Manhattan Project National Historical Parks became part of the NPS on Nov. 9, 2015 with a joint memorandum of understanding between the Departments of Interior and Energy.[5]


[1] For references in this exit, I used my two books on atomic history: Inventing Los Alamos: The Growth of an Atomic Community (Norman: University of Oklahoma Press, 2004) and J. Robert Oppenheimer, the Cold War, and the Atomic West (Norman: University of Oklahoma Press, 2009).

[2] Conversation with Gary Busselman at Hanford Reach, Hanford, Washington, June 1, 2016.

[3] Jill Lepore, These Truths: A History of the United States (New York: W.W. Norton & Company, 2018), 522.

[4] Lepore, These Truths, 570.


[5] Manhattan Project National Historical Parks -- https://www.nps.gov/mapr/index.htm.

No comments:

Post a Comment