Wednesday, June 17, 2020

Exit 42 – Indian Wars at Sand Creek Massacre National Historic Site and Washita Battlefield National Historic Site, Colorado and Oklahoma


             After the Civil War, the U.S. Army continued to fight. It turned to the West and targeted Native Americans who resisted the influx of Europeans Americans into their ancestral lands. I drove to several sites of conscience to probe these final chapters in the Indian wars that had waged since Europeans first landed on the North American shores. Sand Creel Massacre NHS and Washita Battlefield NHS memorialize where U.S. soldiers attacked peaceful villages.
Early in 1864, a band of Indians killed Nathan Hungate and his family southeast of Denver. When their remains were displayed in Denver, cries for vengeance rang out. Territorial Governor John Evans issued a proclamation for “friendly Indian of the Plains” to assemble in safe havens while authorizing settlers to “kill and destroy… hostile Indians.”[1] This set the stage for the tragedy that fell on people who had nothing to do with the Hungate killings.
Gov. Evans (From exhibit at Sand Creek NHS)
Enter Colonel John Chivington, hero of the 1862 Civil War battle at Glorieta, New Mexico.[2] Returning to Colorado, Chivington kept the Glorieta veterans together while adding volunteers. According to Ranger John at Sand Creek, the volunteers were poorly trained, poorly equipped, and poorly disciplined.
On November 28, 1864, Chivington led 675 men with four 12-pounder howitzers onto the eastern plains of Colorado Territory where they descended on a peaceful camp of Cheyenne and Arapahoe. An American flag and a white flag of truce flew above their teepees.
George Bent, son of Owl Woman of the Cheyenne and William Bent of Bent’s Fort on the Santa Fe Trail, witnessed the attack: “By the dim light I could see the soldiers, charging down on the camp from each side… at first the people stood huddled in the village, but as the soldiers came on they broke and fled.”[3]  The soldiers killed indiscriminately as people escaped along the creek’s banks. Some soldiers fired point blank into huddled families.
The ferocity of the attack at Sand Creek illustrates the type of warfare used against Indians. First, European colonists and then the U. S. Army had engaged in total war on Native Americans for centuries. Total war targeted the young, the elderly, and families to break the support and the will which Indian warriors needed for their armed resistance.
In total, 165 to 200 Cheyenne and Arapaho died at Sand Creek, two thirds of them women, children, and the elderly. Another 200 suffered wounds. Of the 675 soldiers, sixteen died, some from friendly fire, and seventy were wounded. Thirteen Cheyenne and one Arapaho chief were killed along with any possibility for peace. Chief Black Kettle survived and continued to call for peace, but Cheyenne and Arapaho warriors retaliated by attacking settlers and wagon trains in the region. The NPS calls the massacre “8 hours that changed the Great Plains forever.”[4]
Contrary to Chivington’s orders, some U.S. soldiers refused to participate in the slaughter. Led by Captain Silas Soule (who had attended peace talks earlier that fall), his company of 100 soldiers did not join the massacre. Soule wrote an eye-witness account: “I refused to fire and swore that none but a coward would. For by this time, hundreds of women and children were coming towards us and getting on their knees for mercy.”[5] What follows are disturbing descriptions of the violence that descended on the camp.
Soule continued with his report: “When the Indians found that there was no hope for them, they went for the Creek and buried themselves in the Sand and got under the banks…. By this time there was no organization among our troops, they were a perfect mob.” As a result, Soule recalled: “One squaw with her two children were on their knees begging for their lives of a dozen soldiers, within ten feet of them all, firing – one who succeeded in hitting the squaw in the thigh, when she took a knife and cut the throats of her children. and then killed herself.”[6]
Some soldiers cut off body parts from dead Indians which they later paraded through the streets of Denver. The Cheyenne and Arapaho did not return to the site nor did the soldiers bury those they killed. In 1868, General William Tecumseh Sherman toured Sand Creek and found human bones scattered around. He sent them back to Washington for ballistic analysis on the effectiveness of the weapons used. These human remains eventually were deposited at the Smithsonian.
After the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act passed in 1990, all federal institutions which held Indian human remains had to contact the relevant tribes to repatriate them. At Sand Creek Massacre NHS, a Repatriation Field on the bluff overlooking the creek bed now holds these remains along with those body parts chopped from the slain that have been returned by descendants of the soldiers. Around the country, some 60,000 types of human remains have been repatriated to tribes who claimed ancestry.
The Reparation Field at Sand Creek in 2016.
In the aftermath of the attack, a Congressional Joint Committee on the Conduct of the War found that Chivington had “surprised and murdered in cold blood…unsuspecting men, women, and children… who had every reason to believe that they were under [U.S.] protection.”[7] Unprovoked attacks, broken treaties, and dispossession of ancestral lands are part of the legacies of conquest that our country continues to grapple with today.
When I first arrived at the Visitors’ Center, Ranger John mentioned that a rifle from that killing field came up for auction, and the NPS bought it. The park then consulted with tribal elders on what to do with it. They asked for the park to destroy it. The NPS did not destroy the rifle, but did not exhibit it either.
I asked John about this. He said that Native Americans look at and understand the past differently than European Americans. He explained that Europeans think of time linearly. All things happen on a distinctive time line. Native Americans understand time cyclically and so tell their histories differently. Tribes transmit their histories orally and when a grandfather tells a story and you retell that story, you tell it as if you are your grandfather. A complication with interpreting such oral traditions emerges since tribal histories are told in their own languages. When the NPS translated those Cheyenne and Arapaho stories into English, this at times changed the narratives.
After talking with John, I walked up the hill to the overlook of the massacre site. It is peaceful now. Crickets chirped along the trail, whippoorwills sang, an owl hooted from the cottonwoods that lined the dry creek bed, a hawk soared overhead. At the top of the hill with the encampment and massacre site spread out below, I imagined the chaos and horror as people frantically fled, and parents dug shallow holes in sand to hide their children. The actual massacre site is off limits. A sign hangs on the overlook barrier: “Help respect sacred ground. Please stay on this side of the fence.” According to John, for Cheyenne and Arapaho today, this park is medicine. It is a healing place. The pamphlet at Sand Creek Massacre NHS states that this place is “profound, symbolic, spiritual, controversial, a site unlike any other in America.”[8]
At the fence overlooking the massacre site below.
Washita continued the tragedy of the Plains Indian War. As Ranger Joel at Washita recounted, Sand Creek was the first act, Washita the second, and  the Battle at Little Bighorn the third. In response of Sand Creek Massacre, warriors from the Cheyenne Dog Soldiers rampaged across the southern Plains to avenge their fallen comrades and family members. As Western historian Paul Hutton said in the movie at Washita Visitors’ Center: “The Army was humiliated. This was the Army that had defeated Robert E. Lee.” Something had to be done.
On November 26, 1868, the Peace Chief Black Kettle had just arrived at his Washita River camp from a strenuous 100-mile mission having requested permission to move his group closer to Arapaho, Kiowa, and the other Cheyenne camps downriver. Permission was denied. His wife, Medicine Woman Later, uneasy with rumors of U.S. troops in the area, wanted to move that night. She had good reason to feel uneasy. At Sand Creek, soldiers had shot her nine times. She survived but now at their winter camp, she had a premonition; however, the council of elders decided to wait until next morning to move.
The Army was indeed nearby. Their Osage and Lenape scouts had found tracks through the snow, possibly Black Kettle’s party returning to camp. The Army decided it led to a hostile encampment. That next morning, as dawn broke, Lt. Col. George Custer and some 700 soldiers of the 7th Cavalry splashed across Washita River, stormed into the campsite, and shot the Cheyenne as they struggled out of their teepees. Warriors desperately fought to cover the retreat of the elderly, women, and children. Medicine Woman Later and Black Kettle hopped on a horse and then were killed as they crossed a creek.
At one point, Ben Clark, a Chief of Scouts, rushed in and told Custer that soldiers were killing women and children “without mercy.” Custer ordered his soldiers to stop shooting and instead take prisoners. The attack lasted only thirty minutes with estimates of forty to a hundred men, women, and children killed. Twenty-two soldiers lost their lives, seventeen of them from Major Joel Elliot’s attempt to chase down those trying to escape. He and his men ran into warriors from the nearby Cheyenne and Arapaho camps riding to the sound of battle. Custer had attacked the weakest camp, and now several thousand warriors from other camps started to surround the 7th Cavalry.
Custer ordered his soldiers to burn lodges and destroy all blankets, food, and supplies to deprive the Cheyenne any sustenance at the beginning of winter. Custer also ordered his troops to kill the Cheyenne horse herd. They eventually shot over 800 animals. From the nearby hills, warriors from the other camps watched in horror, afraid to attack since soldiers had taken captive fifty elders, women, and children. With ammunition running low and a growing force of enraged warriors nearby, Custer feinted a move downriver which sent warriors back to protect their own camps. Relieved of a possible counterattack, the 7th Cavalry and their prisoners stole away into the fading light.
Total war is not new. Union troops torched Shenandoah Valley during the Civil War to remove the Confederates’ source of food. Kit Carson had conquered the Navajo in 1863 with a summer campaign that destroyed crops and homes followed up with a winter attack. When the  starving Navajos surrendered, they were forced on the Long Walk to relocate 350 miles away. The massacre at Sand Creek also occurred as winter set in. At Washita, Paul Hutton concluded: “This was total warfare at its worst. With the dawn attack, they were the most vulnerable…. Total war against the Cheyenne was absolutely effective and forced them onto the reservation.” But he added that the Cheyenne “would have their revenge on Custer and the 7th Cavalry at Little Bighorn.”[9] We drive there next.
As I left the film about the massacre, I noticed another guy in the room with a t-shirt from Fort Pulaski National Monument. I struck up a conversation with Tim Sprano from Lynchburg, Virginia. He is a veteran parkgonaut, having visited 371 of the 400 plus units in the system over the last fifteen years. He remarked that every park has its own reason to exist, so “take what it gives you.” Here at Washita, he commented: “Obviously, we wouldn’t do stuff now that they did 100 years ago. We have different values today than of the past so it’s important to see and hear the whole story.”
After the movie, Park Rangers Joel and Richard spent over an hour chatting with me about what happened at Washita. Richard said this was an important site because people truly learn about our past here. He said: “It’s so much more complicated than just cowboys and Indians…. I thought when I came out here, it would be a lot of black and white and it’s not. There are good guys and bad guys on all sides.”
Joel agreed: “There were not just Cheyenne here, there were a lot of Indians involved and Mexicans too. Half of Custer’s command were immigrants from Ireland and Germany. All these cultures came together by happenstance…. This is part of your heritage, whether you have Indian in you, have soldier in you. It’s part of our heritage – all our warts and blemishes.”
Unlike at the massacre site at Sand Creek, I was able to walk through this tragic landscape. I stopped near the creek where Black Kettle and Medicine Woman Later died trying to escape. Prayer flags hung from a nearby tree. I paused at the meadow where teepees had been ripped open. I passed through the wooded slaughter site of 800 horses. Like most of the battlefields preserved by the NPS, Washita had a quiet resolve broken only by crickets and a faraway farmer plowing a red earth hillside. Nonetheless, the horror of the massacre lay just below the surface of the meadow and woods.

Before contact with westerners, Cheyenne, Arapaho, Kiowa, Comanche, and other tribes of the Great Plains had settled and fought among themselves. Then they got in the way of Manifest Destiny. As they protected their land, their families, and their cultures, they clashed first with pioneers and miners moving through their homelands, and then with the U.S. Army. A Cheyenne Chief, Leg in Water, in 1864 said: “We loved the whites until we found out they lied to us and robbed us of what we had. We have raised the battle axe until death.”[10] 
After the Civil War, the Army used tactics of total war to force Indians to move to reservations and attacked those who refused to go. The exhibit text at the Washita Visitors’ Center concluded: “The tragedy of Washita occurred within this larger story of humanity in conflict. We are still living with the legacies of that conflict—the legacies of Westward Expansion.”

In 2000, Congress (with the help of Colorado’s Senator Ben Nighthorse Campbell, a Cheyenne) passed, and President Clinton signed the bill creating Sand Creek Massacre National Historic Site which opened in 2007.[11] Washita Battlefield became an Oklahoman state park in October 1966 and a National Historic Site on November 12, 1996.[12]



[1] NPS Brochure for Sand Creek Massacre NHS, visited May 2016.

[2] See Exit 32 for Chivington’s story.

[3] NPS Brochure for Sand Creek Massacre NHS, visited May 2016.

[4] NPS Brochure for Sand Creek Massacre NHS, visited May 2016.

[5] https://www.nps.gov/sand/learn/historyculture/the-life-of-silas-soule.

[6] https://www.nps.gov/sand/learn/historyculture/the-life-of-silas-soule.

[7] https://www.nps.gov/sand/learn/historyculture/the-life-of-silas-soule.

[8] NPS Brochure for Sand Creek Massacre NHS, visited May 2016.

[9] “Destiny at Dawn,” documentary film shown at the Washita Battlefield NHS, visited May 2016.

[10] Exhibit text at Washita Battlefield NHS Visitors’ Center, visited May 2016.

[11] Sand Creek Massacre National Historic Site -- https://www.nps.gov/sand.


[12] Washita Battlefield National Historic Site -- https://www.nps.gov/waba.

No comments:

Post a Comment